54321st Poster gets a cookie - mods are cute

Off-Topic (Thronepass)
#26376

Would you rather play a VT that cannot win than a role that dies, but can still win?

#26377

That’s not the dichotemy

If your set-up has a role that cannot win, at the start of the game, it’s a fundamentally badly designed set-up

#26378

Grand Idea is Badly Designed. Not because of any particular role, but because it is possible to roll something that cannot win.

#26379

hosts can reroll things. GI can actually work well with balance taken into account

#26380

how about neither

2 Likes
#26381

You are basically saying hey my class is a little LESS bad then this horrible idea, that’s why it’s a good idea.

1 Like
#26382

Scum can die out N1, making it impossible for them to win. No amount of Rerolling will fix this.

#26383

and they can do things socially to prevent that.

1 Like
#26384

yes

it can actually

#26385

both mine and marshal answer was right

they could do social stuff to prevent being shot by a vigilante, but if there’s a role in the game to kill every scum member N1 then reroll fixes it

1 Like
#26386

Yes, because all town vigis shooting them because they felt like it can be prevented

#26387

to prevent that… dont act scummy

#26388

Bulletproof Third Party Survivor Rolecop

#26389

Why would all town vigilantes shoot them unless they acted so scummy

#26390

Or hell, NK dies because they kill a player who impulsively kills them bypassing immuntiy. NK still loses.

#26391

This is why NK is death immune and the immunity bypass is something that should not be tacked on… easy.

1 Like
#26392

you should be proving why your class is fun to play not why all the other classes in the thread are unbalanced

1 Like
#26393

Strongmanning someone exists.

#26394

Strongman vig bad

#26395

let the host deal with balance

you should be focused on making a fun class