90% of players loved the whisper meta

#181

Did you think I was joking? :stuck_out_tongue:

#182

Why would you want something that is bad for the game to be a viable strategy?

#183

Because I don’t think it’s bad for the game … It’s also easily countered by evils choosing unconventional claims, which I think is a point that most anti-WKMers seem to miss.

#184

Okay but how does that not apply to normal claims lel

1 Like
#185

we really don’t. We were never complaining about it being strong. We were complaining about it being boring

6 Likes
#186

Oh. Well I don’t find it boring and that’s why I want it to remain a viable strategy.

#187

Literally it’s a throne of whispers only discussion is to the king and no discussion happens otherwise

10 Likes
#188

WKM and similar whisper metas is why many people moved to FoL.

FoL is a much more competitively balanced ToL. At first I moved for its more variety in classes but I stayed because I liked the competitive style of play.

I still feel like making my own Mafia style game that is more competitive and based on scumreading.

1 Like
#189

You cant scumread when 90% of ingame talk is through whispering which is a main reason why I dislike whispers.

5 Likes
#190

Personally I don’t dislike whispers in general. But I like them more as a means of following up on leads rather than getting them in the first place

5 Likes
#191

Throne of Whispers is a problem though

4 Likes
#192

why not just say it tho.

unless it’s a claim cc I dont see much other situations

1 Like
#193

I mean like pulling the thread. You notice something that seem suspicious and you whisper to get more information that can finalize the lynch.

3 Likes
#194

It’s not that you can’t do that in the open. It’s just that it’s an acceptable use of whispers

1 Like
#195

Honestly I remember being hunter

Whispering a guy why he executed someone he thought was fool and he got really annoyed to me but then night came and I was Town reading him for his answers I was going to say sorry, but I think you are Town but he died and in his logs he said I was sus lol

1 Like
#196

ok that is cool but still.

players will abuse mechanics

1 Like
#197

whispers just sorta feel like game ruining information holders tbh.

#198

Whispers in FM would be awful tbh

5 Likes
#199

agreed.
you’d have to make a shitton of private dms and moderate them at the same time.

class dms are already a massive burden.

#200

oh dont forget announcing x whispered to y

3 Likes