90% of players loved the whisper meta

Well it’s more then 1 minute

Everyone isn’t active all the time though

So you need a good while

Also 1 minute to scumread also means only 1 minute to come up with the claims and posts being scumread in the first place making slips more common

6 Likes

And I think a minute at night to debrief everything and prepare yourself mentally for the next day

3 Likes

nah I just submitted a bug report over at Discourse Meta

actually the best FMs have a time limit of 300 hours :wink:

3 Likes

they usually have plenty of time remaining too

300 hours seems a while, but that’s only 12 days, and following the FM style

That’s 3 day cycles and 3 night cycles(if we’re assuming all the time is used, and no executions)

Also in ToL in particular scum reading is literally required because of the king

3 Likes

TLDR: Scum reading is real and is much easier to do when people are actually talking (as opposed to whispering)

You should join my next smalltown game

3 Likes

Oh boy, when’s it starting?

Not in the queue yet because time lmao

I’ll see if I can run one in late December/early January

1 Like

Listen, bud, I’ve caught entire evil teams on the internet with text alone. Fully accurate reads over the internet definitely exist.

5 Likes

if you get across a culture where the BD actively talks and posts their reads then the game is far more fun for it, and people can find evils based on it.

For example, if people are actively trying to scumread they’re almost certainly BD. there’s no getting around that.

6 Likes

No meta is perfect. In fact, it has to be flawed at some point in order for the evils to win. if BD won 100% of the time how fun would that be?

Not what this conversation is about

Nuke imagine a 16 p game

1 cop
1 mafia goons
3 godfathers
9 uninformed millers
2 citizens

It’s basically a mind screw but it’s the same thing as 1 god fathers and 2 millers

1 Like

lol

Make it an insane cop

2 Likes