I saw this topic and decided to have some fun with it - my favorite series of this is the Assassin Lottery.
Name: So… what now?
Description: Is it over? Did we get them?
Achieved by: Win on day 2 as BD
Name: I’ll drink to that!
Description: You call that immunity? Ha!
Achieved by: Cause a death by removing night immunity with Happy Hour
Name: A worthy sacrifice
Description: One-for-Six trade, really
Achieved by: Sacrifice a ritualist to get an extra use of Extermination
Name: You, me, and my bear hands
Description: Easiest kill of my life
Achieved by: As an assassin, kill a hunter who has used a bear and survive
Name: Last Laugh
Description: It’d be funny if it weren’t so sad
Achieved by: Fool only win
Name: Last Word
Description: Nice Arrow
Achieved by: Win a game as a hunter via retribution
Name: Evil King?
Description: Nah, couldn’t be…
Achieved by: As King, force execution on the prince
Name: Knight Claim in Current Year
Description: Honestly - just claim Mastermind it’s less likely to get you killed
Achieved by: Survive to day 8 as knight
Name: Assassin Lottery I
Description: You should buy a ticket
Achieved by: Kill a princess n1 who successfully will-o-wisped someone
Name: Assassin Lottery II
Description: Really, buy a ticket
Achieved by: Attack a hunter who chose to bear night 1
Name: Assassin Lottery III
Description: how are you not rich???
Achieved by: Attack someone who a knight has chosen to guard night 1
Name: Assassin Lottery IV
Description: I’m not sure how you managed that, but I’m impressed.
Achieved by: Attack yourself due to being swapped.
Name: Assassin Lottery V
Description: I hate peeping toms
Achieved by: Attack someone followed by an observer night 1
Name: Assassin Lottery VI
Description: I didn’t even kill that guy, honest!
Achieved by: As assassin, get put up after being possessed into someone else
Name: Glad it wasn’t me
Description: I don’t know what they were thinking, I swear
Achieved by: As possessor, get your possessed target killed via knight guard or hunter bear.
Name: The Alch Stands Alone
Description: If people would stop dying you wouldn’t have to be alone…
Achieved by: Winning solo as an alchemist
Name: 4D Chess
Description: And you call yourself a mastermind?
Achieved by: Force execution on the Mastermind as a Good King
Name: That was your first mistake
Description: It was also your last
Achieved by: Kill someone with Rebound as mercenary
Name: Mad with Power
Description: Have you ever tried to go mad without power? Nobody takes you seriously.
Achieved by: Be made king as neutral killer (not sorc)
Name: Turn against your master
Description: If he hadn’t been evil, perhaps things could’ve been different
Achieved by: Kill the physician that raised you as a death knight
Name: Protect your master
Description: You’re like a wall of meat…
Achieved by: Successfully guard the physician that raised you
Name: Confirmed BD
Description: Look the knight CS’d him so he can’t be evil
Achieved by: As a possessor, jump to a different target and leave behind a knight corpse
Name: Keep trying…
Description: I’m sure they’ll eventually kill you
Achieved by: Survive being attacked as Reaper 3 nights in a single game
Name: Freeze out
Description: Don’t worry - I’ll be collecting you shortly
Achieved by: As reaper, use your chill to ensure there aren’t enough votes to put you up
Name: Employee of the month
Description: Probably should have traded up but a win’s a win.
Achieved by: Win a game as merc with your original contract
Name: Money well spent
Description: They kept you alive, didn’t they
Achieved by: Live to the end of the game as a merc contract
Name: Husk Hanging
Description: He shoulda spoken up if he wanted to live…
Achieved by: As a reaper, have a reaped target be executed
Name: No One Escapes Death
Description: That’s cheating!
Achieved by: As a reaper, reap someone who has night immunity
Name: It wasn’t me!
Description: Sure sure whatever you say assassin
Achieved by: As a possessor, have your possessed target get hung in court the next day.
Name: Killer maids
Description: It seems they were strangled in their sleep…
Achieved by: As Noble, have your maid spy target die every night
Name: Investigative Prowess
Description: No such thing as luck!
Achieved by: As Sheriff or Paladin, find two members of the opposing faction two nights in a row.
Name: Persuasive
Description: You’ve such a way with words
Achieved by: As a mastermind, successfully convert 5 players in a single game
Name: Easy come, easy go
Description: There’s always more where they came from
Achieved by: As a cult leader or mastermind, have your convert target put up the next day
Name: Not so pursuasive
Description: … maybe not as smooth as you though
Achieved by: As mastermind, fail to convert 3 players in a row.
Name: High turnover
Description: Good help is so hard to find
Achieved by: As mastermind, have 3 different assassins in a single game
Name: Smooth Criminal
Description: You pulled it off - congrats
Achieved by: As a member of the cult or unseen, be jailed by the prince but not executed when he has executions
Name: Smooth Criminal II
Description: You’re just so trust worthy!
Achieved by: As a member of the cult or unseen, be pardoned after being on trial
Name: Smooth Criminal III
Description: Okay now you’ve gone too far
Achieved by: As a member of the cult or unseen, get one of your accusers executed after you’re put up on trial
Name: 5D Shoots & Ladders
Description: Nobody can comprehend you
Achieved by: Be executed D2 as fool