Announcement: Updated Policy on Replacements

You realize the gamethread is public yes? If people want to learn your scummeta they can just read the gamethread.

Or should we make gamethread private too?

4 Likes

That is exactly the point.
In the gamethread you exactly write just what you want to be public.
But in mafia chat you talk openly. At least I hope so for you.

Which is what you would do if you were told scumchat is going to be public
???

1 Like

oh yeah

we were all like ā€œamelia wonā€™t post we donā€™t want themā€ and then got amelia

that was fun lmao

1 Like

dat: ā€œshould we get a replacementā€
kat: ā€œif its amelia im bussing youā€
marshal: ā€œif its amelia im bussing youā€
kat: ā€œwait i was kiddingā€
marshal: ā€œi wasntā€

4 Likes

also why is ā€œtoo many specs = not enough backupsā€ an argument

when I spec I know full well that I canā€™t be a backup
And a lot of the appeal of spec chat is solving the game / discussing the game with other cool people without having to make an actual commitment to the game for time/stress/other reasons

if I have intention to sub then iā€™ll add myself to sub list

sometimes I might not be interested/committed in a game or spec chat doesnā€™t have many people and so I wonā€™t spec but also probably wonā€™t sub

if iā€™m avaliable and willing to sub iā€™ll put myself of sub list, if iā€™m not, I wonā€™t. Sometimes iā€™ll also be in spec chat but the argument that ā€œspec chat = less subsā€ is wack

1 Like

because spec chat isnā€™t being publicised

Kyo those are two seperate conversations

1 Like

What has this to do with this wtf

1 Like

I mean
I donā€™t know about you
But Iā€™m wishing I could sub into SFoL 62 now, because I donā€™t think I needed to spectate for any other reason than I wanted to talk to people (and make sure that I wasnā€™t being flamed again for Joat9)
:man_shrugging:

1 Like

These arenā€™t two seperate conversations
They play a part in both

Iā€™m ok with not publicizing chats if itā€™s for personal reasons
spec chats more than scum chats and dead chats because spec chats are not actual game threads and instead a private room for people to discuss the game in.

although @anon6348071 I was under the impression the reason you didnā€™t want unseen cord publicized was because of personal reasons and not strategical reasons and now I feel less inclined to disallow people from reading that.

But that spec chat is probably going to be public

1 Like

Well
Then you shouldnā€™t have specced. Most spectators are speccing because they canā€™t play it.

This is literally Moleā€™s entire point

1 Like

and we all shouldnā€™t be talking about this ongoing game so how about we use a different example

4 Likes

This is absolutely absurd reasoning
Do I not have the right to know Iā€™m not being flamed in spectator chats

This is actually disgusting reasoning
Iā€™m appauled

Youā€™re conflating things here tbh