[Anonymous Competitive] - NewD3 - Mafia Wins!

[Venus]

im literally not done yet

[Venus]

unvote, I’m still trying to reach conclusions and you’re giving scum time to coordinate a hammer if shallow is town

[Replay]

Shallow isn’t Town.

[Venus]

bruh just unvote

[KyoDaz]

Votecount

Voted	Voter	Count
Shallow	Replay	1/3
Not Voting	Enigma, Shallow, Telephone, Venus	4/5

[Replay]

Day isn’t over. Easy.

[Venus]

day doesn’t automatically end if town votes town

aaa

[Enigma]

It just requires one of the two being scum who is offline for day not to end tbh lol

[Replay]

I’m so confused. How are votes not locked?

[Venus]

they’re just not locked ???

[Telephone]

Why are we voting

[Telephone]

What

What did I wake up too

[Replay]

but in MyLo/LyLo they’re normally locked, I’m so fucking confused, I hate this.

[Venus]

they’re not now

unvote

[Telephone]

So uh

Shallow and replay are thunderdomed

[Venus]

votes arent locked

[Telephone]

Everyone is online

[Enigma]

@Venus

@Enigma

Enigma is here.

Enigma does not like Replays post. Replay suggesting they would start solving 27 posts in is clearly not viable and they just said it to seem towny.

Enigma will vote Replay.

/Vote Replay

@Enigma

Enigma laughs at you.

Enigma knows that saying “I want to solve” is something scum would do more so than town. Why would town feel the need to say “look at me I want to solve”. Your post was superfluous if you are town yet useful if you are scum.

Enigma also finds your rebuttal overly passive aggressive, again indicative of scum.

@Enigma

Enigma disagrees with your point about voting.

Enigma does like this post a little more however.

Enigma will keep an eye on you.

Enigma/Replay unlikely w/w

@Enigma

Enigma doesn’t understand this read. Enigma is often disliked and has gone through much adversity.

Trying to policy lynch Enigma should not be townread. Explain why you give Telephone a townread for this please.

Yeets my townread on Telephone. Meh

@Enigma

Enigma likes the logic used for this read actually.

@Enigma

Ha. What makes you think this is a fake argument between Enigma and Replay as opposed to a genuine one? Enigma sees nothing to suggest Enigma was involved in SvS there and would like a more detailed explanation.

@Enigma

Enigma knows you are focusing on Enigma to avoid giving real reads on the players.

Give real reads please.

@Enigma

Define interesting.

Enigma finds Scum often use the word interesting to pretend to give reads. Interesting is pretty irrelevant when scum hunting.

all good posts

@Enigma

Enigma will vote Babylon for their unsubstantiated poor read about an SvS with Replay.

/vote Babylon

returns to babylon

@Enigma

Enigma would also like Replay to place a vote as they are still suspicious.

returns to replay

@Enigma

Enigma is laughing a lot.

Being voted 90 posts in is not a push, it’s just a nudge to engage. Nudging to engage is a good thing so Enigma liked the post.

Enigma knows a single vote to make someone engage is not a push.

Your reaction of just focusing in your voter, Paparazzi, and the player who liked the vote, Enigma, reeks of being more focused on self preservation rather than finding scum.

Enigma would like your thoughts on other players.

@Enigma

On what basis do you like Applause? Enigma disagrees. Their reaction to being voted for engagement was to say the voter “smells badly” despite it being normal thing to do.

@Enigma

Enigma did not defend Paprazzi.

You specifically asked Enigma why they liked post. Enigma explains that pressure voting is always good so they liked it.

That is all that happened. Either you have poor memory or are rewriting history.

@Enigma

Enigma likes this logic a lot and gives LoveGame a light townread.

@Enigma

Enigma disliked Venus earlier because they disagreed with Enigma alot, especially on Applause, but Venus is starting to rise a bit on Enigmas reads.

Venus also had this reaction to a vote from Telephone, and Enigma strongly dislikes this reaction:

@Venus

Oh no, I have been voted!!

Oh gosh why did you vote me!!

Enigma is unsure of Venus’ alignment at this moment.

return to me

@Enigma

Enigma recognises this post is slightly useless, Enigma started writing it with the idea of a strong stance but realised Enigma wasnt sure either way.

meh

@Enigma

Enigma thinks Replay has not done enough after original suspicion and is more likely scum than Babylon who Enigma is currently voting.

/Vote Replay

@Enigma

Enigma just ISO’d Shallow (4 whole posts) and agrees, Enigma would be happy with a Shallow hang unless they improve substantially.

Their last post was their worst and most damning in Enigma’s opinion. A number of small things happen in it which combine to really irk Enigma.

@Enigma

No one suspects Enigma? Why? Enigma is not person? Enigma idea. Can you hang idea? No. Enigma immortal. Suspecting Enigma pointless. Enigma always here.

?

@Enigma

You and LoveGame are Enigmas top townreads.

why was telephone top town?
guess it doesnt matter hes gone now
never mentions telephone
weird

@Enigma

Venus has been rising given they are actually trying. Problems arise if players like Shallow and Replay are town and just doing very little - it allows otherwise scummy players to skate by just because they appear to try a bit .

Enigma is saddened.

@Enigma

I’m quoting this but it’s more for the sake of quoting than actually pure thinking? It sparks something in me but I dunno if it’s town or scum, my feelings are strong I imagine

@Enigma

It’s weird but I do believe it comes from town, They want attention, I don’t think their slot in context once again, want attention especially since I do not believe they have much of an impact in this game?

For the people wondering, my stance as of right now is, I’m open to evolving my reads but I feel fairly confidant in the fact one of Venus or Replay could flip scum, Shallow and Applause are my nullreads and Paparazzi and Telephone look townie enough for me

@Enigma

I feel like Applause is town

Calling things cute in Mafia sure is weird, almost sounds like LAMIST, not that I care about that part

@Enigma

ell the one slot that really strikes me as weird is Replay

I still have my doubts on you Venus, seeing how some of your posts do not seem to come from a normal townsperson point of view, some of the arguments you make are technically correct but they do not feel as if they’d come from Town but rather from scum looking for the correct words used to carry town into MLing

But then that seems really

obvious?

@Enigma

Oh I seem to notice Replay v Venus was a thing,

anyway ttyl later gamers going to do boring irl stuff

@Enigma

Replay’s attitude regarding my slot until now had been weird

@Enigma

Meh this feels townie enough for now

why?

@Enigma

From my POV only possible scum distancing is Venus

Venus Paparazzi?

?

@Enigma

To me it’s defensive he says it himself

@Enigma

His jokeposting wasn’t meant to get attention and he actively worries about the effect of his jokeposting

Self aware~ish slot

@Enigma

Lack of confidence and reads make me think it’s more of a townie than anything else

@Enigma

If he’s scum he really TMId Replay slot I feel, the reasoning doesn’t feel strong enough to come from scum reading another scum?

Applause he has a lot more to say, usually it’s easier for scum to justify town reads because they know they’re talking about town, one thing that makes me think Shallow’s town is

@Enigma

it sounds like he’s way more in the moment than most people? also the read itself sounds town the way he focuses on the relation between him posting reads late and being srd is a town line of thinking I believe

@Enigma

Tone seems ok

Doesn’t scream town but I’m fine with it

Content is eh, you can fake all that

The fact he bolded a part of his message makes me want to say the anger is slightly less genuine to my eyes because I know that when I get pressured and am angry, I tend to make my post very simple and short?

@Enigma

Him saying this is probably town aswell, Applause alignment doesn’t matter its the fact he’s willing to call someone locktown from dayplay

@Enigma

Conclusion: probably town wouldnt yeet

???
weird
weird iso
weird conclusion
weird

@Enigma

I don’t really like this

It’s more of a “it’s bad play” than a “its scum play”

Obviously there’s a reason it’s a pressure vote

@Enigma

This is kinda weird

You do all this to conclude on a null read, I don’t really like your reaction to pressure

@Enigma

I don’t know the take is obviously

@Enigma

My slot + Paparazzi

but my slot looks way worse here

why vote Paparazzi

@Enigma

I mean your push either ends here or you stay on my slot

It’s not like it was final 20 minutes of the day you had less of a reason to worry

@Enigma

Line of thought is like eh, like obvious the question is bad but the answer doesn’t look any better to me

@Enigma

Question makes me go ehh

Like you ask the dude who made the post why they put themselves so high

I dunno I believe it is more likely for wolf to not know who they are asking the question to

tinfoil of course

@Enigma

This is giga NAI and NAI posts such as this make me go

ehh why

@Enigma

idk is Venus + self pres that less awful compared to

LoveGame + Paparazzi

I know LoveGame hadn’t flipped yet but eh

@Enigma

Yeah this is probably town

@Enigma

The fact this is the only thing you say after I appear in thread

meh probably town but like

low town, he doesnt push agenda much

still weird iso
less weird conclusion I guess?
meh

meh

@Enigma

Paparazzi

Replay
Venus

le epic game winning poe?

discuss

no bonus points if you call me scum

you never ISO me thought

i still dont really get why you think I’m scum from reading your iso

dont get paparazzi

@Enigma

oh ye lmao

/vote Paparazzi

why vote paparazzi??

still think this iso really sucks

[Telephone]

Theirs no hammer

Thunderdomed

[Venus]

I just quoted posts I wanted to look at later with some notes jesus