[Anonymous Competitive] - NewD3 - Mafia Wins!

[Enigma]

Venus has been rising given they are actually trying. Problems arise if players like Shallow and Replay are town and just doing very little - it allows otherwise scummy players to skate by just because they appear to try a bit.

Enigma is saddened.

[Venus]

I’m going to sleep, I guess. Hopefully Shallow or Babylon get on in the next couple hours.

I’ll try to wake up before EOD.

[Telephone]

Love is probably my top town; you’re one of my tops even though your posting pains me

[Shallow]

@LoveGame

It is now my task to figure out if this is simply mafia trying to blend in, or just a townie who is for whatever reason subconsciously mimicking our typing quirks, and jokes.

Shallow only copy the great DybuDabu

@LoveGame

and @Shallow, what do you think of Paparazzi

I don’t know. The way people post here confuses me and it makes it harder to read people, but maybe I am just shallow. It does seem Paparazzi is trying and that’s something

@Venus

@Shallow @Babylon @Replay can you come talk, maybe give us a read list or at least make some reads?

I don’t have a readlist because I have been somewhat busy

[KyoDaz]

Votecount

Voted	Voter	Count
Paparazzi	Applause	1/5
LoveGame	Babylon	1/5
Venus	Telephone	1/5
Replay	Enigma	1/5
Applause	Paparazzi	1/5
Shallow	LoveGame, Venus	2/5
Not Voting	Replay	1/9

The day will end 2020-07-15T07:00:00Z.

[Telephone]

We need to figure these votes out guys

[Paparazzi]

Oh hi.

If you can’t read the whole game, can you give me your opinion of Replay, Applause and Babylon please?

[Shallow]

I sure can in a bit

[Applause]

Convincing someone you are town is what wolves do, not me. I show.

[Paparazzi]

Maybe instead of arguing semantics, you should actually do that then

[Applause]

Everyone, why are you voting the player your vote currently is?

[Applause]

@Shallow

I don’t know. The way people post here confuses me and it makes it harder to read people

You need to read by actions, analyze what the players are trying to accomplish and either if they would do that as any alignment.

@Paparazzi

Why is this thread so dead?

I believe most people are spending time on their original accounts instead of their alts.

@Replay

I’ve not been involved in conversations so I’ve not been talking much, but here you go.

Town

Replay
Enigma
Venus
Telephone
Babylon
Applause
Shallow
LoveGame
Paparazzi

Scum

Why do you have high opinions of Replay and Enigma, and low opinions of LoveGame and Paparazzi?

Not going to lie, I’m currently enjoying this game. Way less fluffposting.

[Applause]

Just ISOed LoveGame. Reads a wide range of players. Has fresh pushes that are well-explained.

I . @LoveGame you are my top townread as of now. Why should I vote Shallow over Paparazzi?

@Applause

Why do you have high opinions of Replay and Enigma,

Nevermind. Didn’t see you were Enigma. Lol.

[LoveGame]

I think Paparazzi has been putting in consistent effort towards trying to figure things out

they are not townie, but I would much rather somebody asking for clarification on a lot of things and being somewhat proactive with asking questions than somebody who has barely posted, admitted to not having reads, and when Paparazzi asked Shallow for reads on certain players, Shallow left the thread and has not been seen.

[LoveGame]

Work has been very tiring, and I may fall asleep soon, if my claim is needed before I die, I am a TownVanilla.

I suspect I could get CFD-d by you all and wanted to express that if I am not on before End of Day

[LoveGame]

I usually would not claim this, but I realized that I have already accidentally made that clear due to my misunderstanding of the setup, and I want to have no gray area when it comes to that, as the mafia have already likely noticed that, while the town might not have.

[Replay]

@Paparazzi

Why do you read lovegames and myself so low?

Because I don’t exactly scumread anyone right now nor do I really townread people. As it currently stands, I don’t hold many reads. This is changed upon me reading some back in the thread and I won’t post my updated readslist until I decide what I want to post for it.

@Paparazzi

This is pinging me as iffy. It’s like you want to push a mislynch on me, but dont want to be held accountable afterwards

I didn’t have a vote target at the time. Nor are you my vote target for the day anyway. Because I distrust you, doesn’t mean I want to kill you.

@Telephone

Yeah I would love more thought and reasons from @Replay eventually

Would you like my reasonings from the time or my reasons for my new readslist (When I post it after evaluating it). Clearly not many people agree with my reads and I don’t exactly want to be pushed for being a terrible reader in an anonymous game.

@Enigma

Venus has been rising given they are actually trying. Problems arise if players like Shallow and Replay are town and just doing very little

I’m not exactly included in many conversations, nor do I want to randomly insert myself into discussions.

@Enigma

it allows otherwise scummy players to skate by just because they appear to try a bit .

I’m not a good reader. I never have been. This anonymous game isn’t helping.

@KyoDaz

Votecount

This is a horrible votecount, especially considering I’m the only non-voter.

@Applause

Why do you have high opinions of Replay and Enigma, and low opinions of LoveGame and Paparazzi?

I am Replay.
Enigma for his base interaction towards me encouraged to me that he was more than likely Town. Something strikes me odd about LoveGame and Paparazzi, specifically LoveGame, that I just can’t explain. It’s more of a gutread, to be exact.

[LoveGame]

@Replay

Enigma for his base interaction towards me encouraged to me that he was more than likely Town. Something strikes me odd about LoveGame and Paparazzi, specifically LoveGame, that I just can’t explain. It’s more of a gutread, to be exact.

Can you try to elaborate more? It might be difficult, but I do not love when somebody says that something is odd, but does not go into detail.

Were there specific posts that were odd? What exactly is odd?

Try to explain, explore your feelings. You do not love me, but I want to know why.

[Replay]

@LoveGame

Were there specific posts that were odd? What exactly is odd?

Here, let me grab some posts that striked me as odd.

I don't want to fill the thread. Here you go.

@LoveGame

I can not play game on Babylon, as Babylon was the capital city of Babylonia, a kingdom in ancient Mesopotamia, between the 18th and 6th centuries BC.

/vote Babylon

@LoveGame

I cannot, however, play games on Venus, as the atmosphere of Venus is made up mainly of carbon dioxide , and thick clouds of sulfuric acid completely cover the planet.

/vote Venus

@LoveGame

/vote Shallow

@Shallow I do not love you.

@LoveGame

and @Shallow, what do you think of Paparazzi

@LoveGame

Work has been very tiring, and I may fall asleep soon, if my claim is needed before I die, I am a TownVanilla.

But then at the same time you have posts I do like, specifically these ones

@LoveGame

I currently am hoping for more content, from those with the names of

Replay
Babylon
Shallow

@LoveGame

If I had to rank my reads, I would probably put them at somewhere like this.

LoveGame
Enigma
Venus

Applause

Babylon
Telephone
Paparazzi
Replay

Shallow

This post seems well thought out. Apart from Shallow being at the bottom for an unexplained reason and me being at the bottom of Null, although this might just be a random order, it’s not quite clear.

As you can tell, I’m not very sure with you and I’m unsure whether or not I would want you lynched. Right now I would prefer an inactive to be lynched. Even if I’m inactive myself and it’s quite ironic.

[LoveGame]

I have explained my read, on shallow.

@LoveGame

Shallow seems to be copying my gimmick this game, which is to make a comment on your name, and/or a joke about it. Could be seen as blending in.

I might say the same about Enigma, but they have kept up they’re posting way, and so I love them.

@LoveGame

I do not have concrete proof of that, however the comedic instance of “comment on your name” is rare enough that I think there is a highly likely chance they were doing it, as a copy of my typing style, and comedy.

What I am trying to figure out is if copying my comedic fixation on your name is wolf indicative, and if so, how much.

I think a semi-likely theory is that Shallow is Mafia, who is trying to blend in, either consciously or unconsciously, by copying my joke.

This is not hard evidence, but as there are only 121 posts in the game thread, this is the person who I want pressure on the most.

These were before I posted the read list, and were my reasoning.

I have elaborated, later down, even more.

@LoveGame

Also shallow’s continued behavior of not only referring to themselves in the third person (which is what enigma is doing, and fits with my blend-in read)

@Shallow

Shallow love SoD joke vote

But this is also directly copying my writing style, which is seen in my posts below:

@LoveGame

I love Telephone

@LoveGame

I love game

Even the incorrect grammar is copied, which makes me sure that Shallow is just mimicking the writing styles of more prominent players.

It is now my task to figure out if this is simply mafia trying to blend in, or just a townie who is for whatever reason subconsciously mimicking our typing quirks, and jokes.

I also believe that shallow not commiting to doing the reads that they promised to do is a poor look, as mafia members often times do not feel the need to fake solving, and feel less inclined to honor their promises to help advance town because they are not town.