‘why would I lie about that’
I think the explanation that makes the most sense there is that you went for something that has, like, slight grounding in reality (‘Arete treated Centuries and Bo112 differently’ such that it would be hard for me to call out how you were misrepresenting what I was actually doing)
and like
I’m not going to pretend that I treated them 100 percent identically
but that completely ignores the fact that … they did not openwolf 100 percent identically … like the ‘is this actually a villager’ comment was in response to Bo’s hydra partner getting on, apologizing, and starting to actually solve the game, as opposed to Conroy continuing to be like ‘just vote me out’ and then self hammering
and also
you aren’t even trying to consider what alignments make my treatment of Conroy make sense
you’re just making a sucky meta argument that isn’t even supported by what I actually did in the game you’re comparing to and being like ‘well it’s different so Arete is wolf’
rather than trying to figure out why it’s different