sulit its almost 1am go the fuck to sleep
their posts didnāt make me physically cringe
they donāt look like they want to commit die
they feel natural in thread
they made posts that donāt suck
disclaimer iāve only played with ici like twice and i could probably do some W!Ici research but i wouldnt touch today
1 Like
Im still reading but does like anyone have a read on Mist, after last game i learned i have 0 good way to read her.
ok Iām bored so Iām going to do some Isos
starting with Solic because he has the fewest posts and Iām lazy
I think this is slightly >rand V, specifically the part about being happy that it could get rerolled because he wanted to be scum, I think it would be sort of unlikely for scum to think of something like that
ok this isnāt super relevant to Solicās alignment but Iām really curious if Marshal saying this was villagery was an actual read because this post seems ~completely NAI
kinda mindmelded with this post a bit? probably a good look
this post is kind meh, they quoted a massive wall and basically just said āI like thisā with like one piece of elaboration, it feels vaguely pockety
[quote=āSolic, post:631, topic:84772ā]
This level of sass reads frustrated townie to me that is probably not having the best day, feel better Birdo
ESPECIALLY, since they seem to have the morals of taking the high road when scum as seen by
this one is a bit better, I think the depth of thought and nuance in this post is a good look for Solic. It also doesnāt really feel like the sort of read scum would think to fake?
also, a thing I notice throughout Solicās Iso is that heās being kind of pedantic about minor details, like here
and here
I think that sort of pedantry is likely to be >rand V, wolves tend to be more focused on placating people whereas Solic doesnāt really see concerned about that? you could argue that heās doing it for towncred but he doesnāt really seem to be trying to milk cred from it
the rest of his posts after that seem basically NAI, he asks some questions but theyāre not, like, super AI for him
overall Iād say Solicās a townlean, he only really had a couple of posts that pinged me and a bunch of posts that I found slightly townie. Not super confident on this given that his postcount is so low, but I donāt really want to go here today.
thread is basically dead minus for arete posting isos
ive like, kind of read geyde/orange who i didnt really bother reading before
The point about Geyde being angry thus meaning heās scum with a pretty townsided townteam is ehh, Geyde is an annoyed DUMBIE 99% of the time so I wouldnāt really call that very ai, Reading Geyde doesnāt really give me any vibes, feels very different than everyone else
I think Hippo has made a few posts that sounded pretty genuine, they were about his meta though, I donāt think tone is unfakeable from him but itās > rand v, could trend down
I agree with Mist concerning how Orange feels similar to his play in Umineko, not that I wanted to remember that game, Iāve never seen scum Orange iirc so I donāt know how different he is as scum, > rand v aswell
Ici apparently is obvious town, Iām fine with the read
will be back later
going to play games
Weāre pretty close to having a very good number of consensus townies btwbtw, assuming prs arenāt among very top consesus town :^)
Hippo Iso
opens with memeing
more memeing
I donāt want to read too much into this because Iām pretty sure he opens with memeing as both alignments
in context heās replying to Geyde and Vulās votes on him (n.b. he hasnāt made a read on either of them at this point), I didnāt really notice it at the time but now that Iām actually reading and ā¦ noticing that Hippo hadnāt made a read on either of them ā¦ this feels like a kind of wolfy way to avoid actually addressing the suspicion on him
I think this is a slightly villagery thought to express, like, in W!Hippo V!Dat worlds I think it would be more advantageous for Hippo to just not say that and let Dat keep softdefending him
thin read but itās there
I feel like Hippo has a lot of posts like this, where he says someone could be Mafia and doesnāt really explain it at all, it feels like shade given the lack of elaboration + the way he expresses it as āX could be Mafiaā rather than making an actual read, which in my experience is often a sign of a wolf trying to get someone yeeted without taking responsibility for it (my read on Geyde aside)
although he explains it a little later, which is better, didnāt see this until I scrolled down
spends a bunch of time talking about katās PR claim, I donāt really like this. realistically itās not going to accomplish anything besides outing PRs and thereās not really a good reason to do it as town
part of this might be hindsight from kat rescinding :wowee:
not really seeing the progression on his Geyde read, he goes from āGeyde could be Mafiaā to āGeyde probably townā with no intervening steps
@Hippolytus can you clarify how you got from Point A to Point B
I think him calling Vul a ābitchā is slightly >rand V though
like if heās a wolf insulting Vul isnāt going to do anything but make Vul annoyed with him and thereās no reason to be antagonistic like that as scum
then he spends a bunch of posts complaining about people scumreading him
I donāt think any of these are particularly AI in either direction but the sheer volume of his Iso thatās just complaining about being scumread isnāt great, like, I get that no one likes being scumread as any alignment but itās legitimately like half his Iso
Overall conclusions
overall Iām not feeling great about Hippo, he had a couple posts that pinged me as slightly villagery but his overall posting is Not Great, and his primary focus of the game for basically the entire second half of his Iso is complaining that people are wolfreading him
would be fine with a Hippo yeet today
I should probably go to sleep, itās pretty late here
see you all in the morning
would appreciate thoughts on my Isos
?
if speaking objective truths is villagery thenā
:wowee:
time to enter the Vulgard Wallpost Waiting Room and then probably sleep before he finishes cause itās 4:30AM and ive been half asleep for like 6 hours 
1 Like
given that kat has now claimed and rescinded āunspecified PRā I think itās not going to hurt anything to out this, I had a wolf-or-PR read on kat at the time
thereās some potential village motivation in wanting to know if someone is really an unCCād PR because it means theyāre basically confirmed town and you donāt have to sort them, like SAG with Mistslot in our hydra game
i should start playing on a different account maybe
i honestly forgot he even posted this
thatās how little impact his posts have had on me this game
?probably? not a good sign but i canāt really say for sure
this post is leaning very close to village arete
what a surprise
also a village arete post
three in a row
i think youāre giving him too much credit
yeah iām starting to trust arete
same with you which is why iām not giving you a free pass
my reads are garbage until i start isoing people so i canāt agree unless i iso him again
iām getting the opposite impression but it could be just me being bad at fm
you hosted one
evolution mafia
reads like entertained wolf
wait how has datbird not managed to make a single read yet?? am i missing something
oh finally he scumreads marshal
i donāt want to preflip but this specific paragraph about marshal feels like a wolf talking about a villager