Still should keep a very close look at the two. Bad logic does not mean town.
Mind explaining the reasoning there?
No I originally scumread him and then the reasoning Geyde brought up made sense. I do townread him now but I get these weird gut feelings saying that he is scum.
I do get where you can get that idea from though.
I was never making that argument, rather responding to what you had to say.
It’s not necessarily indicative of him being scum or not that he read the OP.
I do actually believe this could be the case. However, the quick change in opinion could mean 2 scums talking to eachother. I dont know the FOL community well enough to use the past games logic so i am going off pure actions from this game.
Colleagues, dear ladies, dear gentelman.
You said bad reason voting does not make someone town. If you imply that being suboptimal in chosing reasoning for voting is not enough for town reads, in my experiment I tried to prove if taking it step ahead and voting without any reason at all does provide others with a reason to town read me.
1 Like
Well i was a little taken aback by the vote but im gonna finish my thesis
HTM’s logic for the quick change in opinion does possibly make sense. However, that last sentence really rubbed me the wrong way. It felt like something scum would say to get their buddy out of the spotlight without making the connection between them and their buddy.
Especially in this mode when 2 scum being found is a loss, the last comment just doesnt feel right.