Bleeding + Poison Merge

Feedback/Suggestions
#21

Even if they aren’t the same status, it’s mechanically the same.

There is no use in having 2 identical functions, and all it does is prove which faction is in the game. It doesn’t give more room to distinguish between poison and bleeding, unless you want to make them entirely different things.

7 Likes
#22

I think maybe we should have them do different things

All Bleeding should notify the target that they’re bleeding out, but poisoned targets will be hidden, and only be notified that they’re going to die to poison at the start of the night they’re going to die

#23

For example:

Hunter’s Wolf / CL’s Rupture / (Hopefully Assassin’s Dagger will be changed to Bleeding)

Bleeding will notify the target that they are bleeding, and will always kill them on the second night. Hunter’s Wolf should probably work during the day instead of the night to remove confirmability.

Nightshade Wine / (I think Alchemist’s Emerald Potion should poison)

Poison will be hidden, so the target will not be notified until the start of the night that they’re going to die. If a Physician or Alchemist cures it, they’ll see this as poison.

However, they can be healed in some marginal cases, i.e. Mystic Conduits a poisoned Knight with a Physician, Knight tells Phys he’s poisoned, Phys heals etc.

1 Like
#24

That’s too OP though

Assassin should try to get healers out and then use it or use it for a distraction

#25

Assassin would be moving to Bleeding

#26

Oh okay

I’m fine with this

#27

Not fine with hunter killing in two nights.

1 is his specialty and pretty much makes it’s less useful than to just hang them

#28

We can just change both Wolf and Bear to Day Ability

#29

As long assassin doesn’t have this I’m fine

#30

Not two nights though l. Disagree with that

#31

Oh I misread, Hmmmmmmmmmm, then do we have the Hunter poison?

#32

ITS A WOLF. No

#33

Is the wolf now venomous?

#34

0 night abilities though is bad

While wolf should be a day ability bear doesn’t

#35

I don’t know, but the thing is that it auto-confirms Hunter as the only night bleeder

1 Like
#36

So?

hunter is a good claim for neutral killers, not cult leaders and stuff.

#37

But Hunter has bleeding, not regular attack

#38

So?

I rather a neutral killer be able to do it than a cult leader or assassin.

It makes hunters more sus and hunter is the only decent claim as a neutral killer.

1 Like
#39

I guess

#40

I once became psycho king that way.

Then a hunter cc’d me. We put up the hunter. And I said YOUR DYING WITH ME" and that was that

1 Like