Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

[Italy]

Each night, you learn how many of your 2 alive neighbors are evil.

[Tangeld]

Do I spy a game mechanics question? Why are we not asking these in class DMs? I distinctly recall saying words like that at some point…

[Arete]

the Useless Empath: learn how many of your nearest townsfolk neighbors are good

[Arete]

But yeah, Empath is alive players only.

[Tangeld]

Words, words, words… Oh, there it is!

Ah, it was in a whisper channel because someone kept asking questions in whispers. glares at no one in particular again

[eevee]

Hmm, paradoxaly I should heal Maxwell tonight, to prevent passing the role to baron, in case the gamesolve is not complete.

And it probably isn’t.

It never is that easy.

[Italy]

Imp will always starpass to the Scarlet Woman if one is in play. No matter what.

[Italy]

I suspect that Isaac is the Baron.

[Italy]

It doesn’t matter what Magnus comes up
Spy
Investigator
Soldier
What reason would he have to double up on a claim if he knows that role is in play anyways?

[Italy]

Thus completes our gamesolve closes book

[Isaac_Gonzalez]

lol no

[Italy]

Why would the Spy double up on a claim?
Enlighten us.

[eevee]

Cause possibly Magnus is a baron, not spy?

[Italy]

If he’s baron, we’ll know.
Spy’s ability can’t make it look like a different evil.

[Italy]

That’s why we kill magnus first.
/hands u-
…oh right
GOD DAMN IT

[Isaac_Gonzalez]

you know i was the one who counterclaimed right tell me why i would do that as scum

[Tangeld]

Italy, you’re one of the few people I know who so regularly forgets that they’re dead.

[Italy]

yes well this is kind of my first time
not so much of a first time for you, of course

[Tangeld]

You act like I’m above putting Hell’s Librarian into play…

[Italy]