Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

Forum Matches Completed
#3665

It’s technically possible Possessed is a wolf and that’s why the kills were so good, and he starpassed

I don’t think it’s likely, but it is in fact possible

he’s sitting next to Kyo though so Kyo would have been malfunctioning

#3666

I could if his goal is to make himself look the least spy like possible

#3667

I don’t think that’s how Wazza would play scum although this is admittedly mostly based off of one game (SFoL 51)

#3668

For reference in this game he messed up his fakeclaim but mostly because he misread the class card for the class he was pretending to be

#3669

I can take that into consideration i have a little conversation with them based off of Max messaging them but it leads not where and it seems this was near game start and none of recent activity.

Also i only just realized that we are limited to base lists and was trying to figure out which killer it was. (Its an Imp but that’s my fault)

1 Like
#3670

Here’s my gamesolve

  1. Eevee - Monk
  2. Italy - Ravenkeeper
  3. Arete - Mayor
  4. Shurian - Saint
  5. Marshal - Scarlet Woman -> Demon
  6. DirectorHail - actual real Butler
  7. Simon - Drunk-or-channelmasterified Washerwoman
  8. Nerbins - Fortune Teller
  9. Frostwolf103 (replaced by Isaac_Gonzalez) - Baron
  10. WazzaAzza - Poisoner
  11. Maxwell - Librarian
  12. Magnus - Imp
  13. Possessed - Undertaker
  14. KyoDaz - Empath

with the unused one of {Drunk, Channelmaster} most likely being one of me, Eevee, and Italy

I can explain why I think any given player I identified as scum is the scum class I labelled them as, and/or why I put the scum exactly where I did, but probably not right now, it’s an hour later than I was planning to go to sleep :eyes:

@Magnus @Isaac_Gonzalez @Wazza @Marshal if this is right you all collectively owe me a cookie after the game

3 Likes
#3671

currently running with the ‘there is no Spy, Magnus just killed random people and got lucky’ theory

#3672

After reading the flips and around them k could agree they seem slightly random and people mentioned that more so after the fortune teller died and is a good possibility.

Wouldn’t be surprised IF to were attacked one and the redirection happened onto one of them from you Infinite Passive. (If you are indeed mayor)

1 Like
#3673

Magnus is in fact the sort of player I could see killing targets basically at random

#3674

this feels too obvious

maybe it just actually is that obvious

#3675

Who ninja-slammed Hail? I think that’s our demon.

#3676

no cookie for you im soilder

#3677

noob

#3678

sober? possibly
healthy? ehhhhhh its kinda hard to be nice and healthy when your dead

although i will say, perhaps thats why they kept him alive so long, the thought he was drunk, and it wasnt until he identified their imp that they knew for sure

#3679

Magnus is the type of player to not kill at all.

#3680

Magnus could also be the type of player to get 3 unused fakeclaims and not take any. In which case it might be 2 v 2 right now.

#3681

'Scuse me sir, I slammed hail.

1 Like
#3682

In public, mind you.

#3683

honestly, even if its 2 v 2 here it doesnt make the situation more dangerous for town.
it affects gamesolving, but we can still nolynch safely here

#3684

next day its 1 town 2 evils, but evils dont auto win in that scenario