Blood on the Forums: Trouble Brewing [Good wins]

Forum Matches Completed
#5045

see thats the thing tho, people can be really good at acting towny
mechanics or rng can spite you occasionally.
but solid logic cannot be faked or muddied

except mechanics didnt.
neither did reads.
logic did
i had no idea what anyone’s roles were pretty much, and had zero motivation-reads on shurian. the main reasons were that everyone’s pushes on me made sense, and arete had some solid evidence behind him (plus that i liked his actions a good bit)

i know im pumping it up a little bit too much, but im still just giddy that it worked.

#5046

Yeah that was when I was like
“What the fuck”

When Isaac suddenly became town and eevee becane scum I was like
“Fuck”

#5047

So my ‘Isaac is evil because Tan wouldn’t have given two good as Saint’ deduction was Technically Correct

#5048

In fairness, I probably should have noted what bluffs Demon was given on the Grimoire (that’s also why I ignored the question when Arete asked me whether Demon bluffs would be on the Grimoire; I didn’t do that and immediately realized that I should have).

1 Like
#5049

dies

#5050

Craziest part is that if Magnus had killed me, there wouldn’t BE a thunderdome. Isaac could have very well been alive to F3. I think that was a big mistake.

#5051

> be Spy
> literally have perfect information
> counterclaim your Demon

#5052

Arete, you should have immediately taken the Saint ping with a grain of salt. The whole point of Saint is that they’re not supposed to be mechconfirmed, otherwise they basically just become a vanilla townie (because no one’s gonna hang a mechconfirmed Saint until they have to), so making a Saint ping as Librarian rather defeats the purpose of Saint as a character.

1 Like
#5053

before step 1 you have to be isaac

#5054

so eevee was secretly 90000000 IQ

#5055

by the way eevee already had both me and magnus claims and we have no communication so me and magnus were forced into a thunderdome

#5056

You couldn’t have died before Eevee; he was parked on you every night.

#5057

yes

#5058

my reasoning for simon good still stood.

and i couldn’t predict shurian yoloclaiming saint lmao

#5059

Did you know hard it was to keep up a Saint part

And be like “huehue imma stabby stabby” in the background

#5060

That’s the funny part: They both wouldn’t know that the other picked one claim with Eevee’s plan. All they’d know is that Soldier claim doesn’t exist.

1 Like
#5061

Even when he didn’t trust me? What a hero.

#5062

I think my reasoning was solid it just lost to yoloclaim

#5063

quick question.
exactly how much did you panic when we were saying “scum definitely kills shurian tonight”

4 Likes
#5064

That actually should have been a point we discussed in electing Shurian.