They do, yes.
Then respectfully, Iām not claiming to you even though I know what you are softing, as this could be a gambit to get all claims from town and clear you and possessed.
Scum know who their allies are, but not necessarily which characters. Example:
A is a Minion. They were told during Setup night that B and C are their fellow Minions, and that D is the Demon. They donāt know which Minion characters B and C are, however.
(They also technically donāt know what type of Demon D is, but TB only has one Demon type, so moot point.)
This isnāt going to work unless you put faith in this process.
Itās either we are both scum, orā¦ Iām spy who knew all roles.
And spy knows all roles anyway, so claiming to me changes nothing.
If we allow for random whispers to happen, the chance that spy will give information for rest of the team is very high.
If we however orgainze it toward one preson who is confirmed by someone, information can make us play way more optimaly, while reducing chance that evils will pass all info.
What I suggest is building a consensus before you all mass claim, but it needs to be done today or scum will have too much time to coordinate their claims.
Whispers in itself are very suspicious, EXACTLY cause most evils have no information and need to pass it to each other.
Iām trying to organize it, to prevent it, while making exchange of info for town unhindered.
I respectfully decline. Yāall can say itās because i ādont have a fakeclaim yetā but iāve already softed so idgaf.
If you are spyā¦ whispers go two ways. You would be able to spread everything to your freinds. So iām not for this plan.
Either you trust Iām town here, and I have someone confirming me.
And this way we block most other whispers, making scum uncoordinated, or we play fully randomly.
I will of course pass all relevant info you want to pass, but I kinda want all whispers to go through me or eventually through Possessed rn.
Are you town looking to win?
Whatās stopping me to do so if whispers go fully random?
Likeā¦ if we donāt organize it, people could whisper whoever they want.
I donāt like this comment.
ādo my plan or lose the gameā is the dumbest argument ever.
so no
You say that I wouldnāt whisper my teammates to pass the info if I was spy, if everyone could whisper whoever they want?
Why do you think things would fall to chaos if we donāt follow lord eevee?
You are saying itās your plan or a dystopia and im not a fan.
For the record, iād give you a 75% chance of being town. But I also am gonna be wary and respectfully decline.
So you suggest that we ban all whispers?
Put this into perspective: There are only unique classes. If evils claim a duplicate class, theyāre exposed. Niceā¦easyā¦simple.
They are also classes which can confirm other people, this might save us a misslynch without someone like empath outing.
you know what? I give in.
/whisper eevee
sigh.
/whisper Marshal
This is only gonna work if everyone does this or we will have a boatload of mislynches. So pleaseā¦all claims to Eevee in a fashionly order.