Seriously, read my posts. I’ve been pushing Town in the right direction all game.
Scum have 4 votes in total
Town has 10 votes in total
Assuming Italy was town (which I very much trust) and subtracting 1, that makes 9
this means that 4 townies can fail to vote and if the rest of us vote correctly we win
or 5 townies can fail to vote and if we tie it we can Mayor-win
That is WHY I AM LITERALLY TRYING TO LEAD YOU INTO THE RIGHT DIRECTION.
Have you NOT SEEN WHAT I’VE BEEN DOING ALL GAME.
I have been incorrectly naming scum and everything.
I. WAS. NOT. SCUM.
That’s why I’ve been calling Possessed scum! For fucks sake!
I so think scum was laughing this entire game.
How you can win is simple, Arete has it mostly figured out.
what if Italy’s right
what if Shurian/Maxwell actually is W/W
let me go figure out if that’s possible-given-reasonably-plausible-circumstances
…okay I’m going to be totally honest, I can’t see literally any reason for a townie to counterclaim an in-play role, then switch to CCing a different in-play role, then claim Poisoner and ask to be executed
2 Scum = Impossible.
Game would end.
- I had no idea there was going to be nor there was a Mayor in play. That’s why I whispered you in the first place after the CC.
- I had nothing else to do. Either me or you were going to be lynched and I’d rather myself get lynched over an actual Mayor. My role was useless as fuck, seriously. I already had my knowledge so I had no reason to stay in the damn game any longer.
in that scenario, we don’t have a Baron, meaning instead we have a Poisoner, a Spy, and a Scarlet Woman
also in this scenario the evils are Maxwell/Shuri/Wazza/{Magnus, Isaac} which means no one else is evil
since there’s no Baron, there’s a Channel-mastered person but not a Drunk
Simon definitely got false information and in this scenario is confirmed Good, meaning that he’s either the Channel-mastered person or the N1 poison target or Magnus is just the world’s most questionable Spy or Imp
Possessed maybe got false information in this scenario as well, depending on Magnus’s class, in this case on N3, but he got true info N1 and N2.
everyone else has not confirmably malfunctioned but that doesn’t mean they can’t have
I don’t think Imp!Magnus, nor Spy!Magnus, would claim an in-play role, and in this scenario Magnus/Isaac is TvS. so Possessed in this scenario was malfunctioning N3, meaning that either he was Poisoned (which means he was Poisoned N2 as well), or he’s channel-mastered. if he’s Channel-mastered then Simon was poisoned N1
basically what I’m getting here is that it’s very technically possible but really really unlikely
also Shuri and Maxwell aren’t next to each other, so they’d have to be coordinated
tl;dr Magnus/Shuri highly unlikely to be W/W, Shuri nearly-certain to be Good
1 Like