Shutupandletmefeelsmart
and yet, botc shenanigans with a combo of poisoner on the washerwoman, and drunk on the chef, and the storyteller being an annoying bastard that likes cool coincidences (in this hypothetical. yall are cool tangeld and priestess) and it becomes possible
yet still it is very unlikely so you roll with it and assume it true
If I was evil here, I would actually be flipping tables.
You can look at literally any scum game i’ve ever played.
Technicly speaking, Italy was not redchecked.
The real monk is just confirmed via other town role as non-scum.
Check was on monk, not on Italy.
Plus real monk actually was putting a lot of effort in solving and I can see theirs town motivation, but that’s not mechanical.
Whole thing was basing on thunderome and Italy just haaving way worse position in it.
I’d just be really angry because this would be the third game in a row i died before N2 on
hearing people actively discarding parts of stories and probabilities (y’know, like you’re doing right now, discarding every probability that doesn’t somehow loop into “Italy and arete are evil”) is the most stressful thing that ever happens to me in text games
and you are not helping
okay so I just had the WORLD’S DUMBEST THOUGHT
but if we have a fortune-teller running around, Italy is strongly indicated to be a Minion at this point, and also very unlikely to be Spy based on the double-claim, so he can’t be the Red Herring
what this means is that if you’re trying to narrow down a yes you can use Italy as a guaranteed no
this is really dumb but technically correct
I’m actually considering what you say, you know?
Look, others are jumping to the gun, but now it’s time to really actually consider if it makes sense.
