What about prophet, amnesiac, bounty hunter, lion tamer, and coachman
updated idea:
townsfolk
prophet
bon viviant
mole (altered from standard; he receives an out-of-play minion to bluff as)
magician
lion tamer
astrologer
bounty hunter
amnesiac
pixie
knight
stableboy
coachman
scavenger
outsiders
golem
plague doctor
hermit
golden child
minions
wizard
marionette
psychopath
goblin
demons
al-hadikha
lleech
creeping terror
palabra de dios
i know ur probs not playing (which is okay), but i have approval to run this so long as i change the names of all classes once im done
1 Like
of course i knew this with how your experience w/ BotF 2 went. like i said, that’s okay
the purpose of this thread, though, is to provide balance feedback on the formation of this setup, not to express whether or not you would play it
If you’re replacing something for Noble, I’d be inclined to suggest Knight, as both are starting-info characters, but you could avoid the issue of Travelers by swapping Prophet out for Noble. And I’d suggest a small tweak to Coachman, in that they can’t use the same word twice (I wouldn’t be the least bit surprised if a Coachman player said “Demon” every time).
1 Like
Which two between noble, knight, and prophet do you think would be best balanced? Note that I don’t really have an issue with forcing released travelers to be permitted since I like the prophet’s ability so much. And got it for coachman. I should probably also say that you cannot use another word that is blatantly a direct synonym to a word you have already used.
Also, if psychopath is triggered by plague doctor, I plan to have either marshal or me be given the psychopath ability (but not both) and the town can lynch + RPS THAT st without fear of consequence to get rid of the psychopath ability. Does that sound okay?
Oh, ick, I didn’t even realize the interaction between Plague Doctor and Psychopath. I mean, that really only happens in a 3-Minion game that rolls PD and not Psycho (since having any option other than Psychopath for PD allows you to just not use Psycho for it), but that seems like an okay way to deal with it.
In terms of balance between Noble, Knight and Prophet, I would think that Noble and Prophet gives the best balance, but the interaction between Noble and Bounty Hunter gives me pause, since Bounty Hunter getting anyone within Noble’s three would confirm the other two as good, which can be devastating for evil.
Also marionette can’t really be done as a result of plague doctor or be given to mole as a bluff. So that might limit us to 2 minions / 12 residents
Do you have a solution to that @Tangeld
i like marionette but it’s possible we have to get rid of it
If marionette does not roll in a 3 minion game with Mole, I think good is fucked
Oh, for… Mole doesn’t play nicely with Psychopath either. This is why it’s in Midnight, with the Goblin and Wizard as the Minions known to be in that script; it has deniability when it can’t perform a public Minion action.