BotF IV discussion thread

Forum Matches Discussion
#81

This would also permit SW

#82

Snitch works fine with that, yeah. Snitch just runs by showing three bluffs to the Minions along with who the other Minions and the Demon are, and you would show the same three to each Minion (otherwise Snitch becomes even more punishing). And remember that the three bluffs given to Minions are allowed to overlap with the Demon’s three bluffs.

1 Like
#83

which 4 are best from the set of 5:
{goblin, mephit, wizard, SW, poisoner}

#84

I kind of like the first 4?
Poisoner could work as a mole bluff but mole can get fucked if demon is able to prove someone not being poisoned somehow

#85

townsfolk

prophet
bon viviant
mole (altered from standard; he receives an out-of-play minion to bluff as)
magician
lion tamer
astrologer
noble
amnesiac
pixie
knight
stableboy
coachman
scavenger

outsiders

golem
snitch
hermit
charlatan

minions

wizard
mephit
goblin
scarlet woman

demons

al-hadikha
lleech
creeping terror
palabra de dios

#86

Remember that Al-Hadikha and Scarlet Woman have a jinx on them.

#87

ah dang it
Could djinn do anything about that

#88

I don’t even really know what djinn does

#89

Djinn is “Jinxed characters are not both in play, but evil players know which ones are, or declare that the Djinn’s Special Rule is in effect to resolve the jinx.”

#90

Also why does al-hadikha jinx with SW? i dont really understand

#91

would it be too powerful in terms of KP or something

#92

Which of these two options would you say would be better to resolve this jinx

#93

In the case of Al-Hadikha and Scarlet Woman, the jinx is because Al-Hadikha can bring people back to life, so the Scarlet Woman who becomes Al-Hadikha could choose to bring the original Al-Hadikha back to life, and the Special Rule is that if the Scarlet Woman turned Al-Hadikha does this, they turn back into the Scarlet Woman.

#94

I defined this character wrong in my pdf then
what does it actually do

#95

Al-Hadikha: At night, 3 players choose whether they live or die. But if they all choose life, they all die. (Dead players who choose live come back to life).

#96

I like this rule. So it’ll be in with Djinn

#97

What does this mean

#98

How is it different from them just staying alive

#99

If Al-Hadikha chooses a player who is already dead when chosen, and that player chooses life, they come back to life.

#100

AH
didn’t know that