Castle Desolation - Apprentice, WindwardAway, Italy, Nightingale and Gorta are victorious!

think so
but the first(?) seal where he walked into the room right after amelia found the broken seal is what i was thinking
unless it was just amelia and marl in cahoots giving each other alibis, but then again idk why amelia would repair the LoH in that case

Unless Amelia is covering for Marl, both seals were broken by Whys (I have reason to doubt this), Emilia (I have reason to doubt) or Amelia.

man, i have reasons to doubt all of them except amelia, but idk why he would repair the LoH unless his wincon is to break seals and not look suspicious lol

1 Like

i mean reasons to doubt that they broke seals

1 Like

Whys is a flipped good.
Emilia is either the best bluffer ever or is good.
Amelia is someone without alibis (since they were the discoverer of the seals being broken) and also I still don’t know what to think about them.

Marl’s deffo evil.
But has an alibi via Amelia’s claim.

Which means either Marl is the breaker and Amelia lied for them meaning they’re both (probably) evil.
Or Amelia might just be the seal breaker.
(Or something’s really wrong and Emilia is big brain af)

if Emilia is big brain enough to pull this off, she’s fooled me too lol
but i doubt it

1 Like

Same here.
To me I have Amelia as evil af either way.

Meaning @Hippolytus since you need an evil executed, myself (and Wind) are fairly sure Amelia might be it.

1 Like

I do appreciate your continued ignoring of the fact that if I broke the seals, I hard poed myself with my own actions

In fact, it seems evident you’re not even considering it

I have considered it.
It’s just sadly for you everyone else actually has alibis.
So it doesn’t matter what you’re saying.

I mean if you’ve considered it, you’ve failed to once mention it

Might I add, wasn’t it you who’s insisting emilia has an alibi

You, who covered for an evil player, allowing him to murder two players then escape?

I said Emilia has an abili?
No I said it’s VERY unlikely Emilia is evil and broke a seal.
And Wind also agreed on that.

I mean you have said that before so

But it’s fine

@Arctic in order to convince these nerds I’m totally willing to be lie detected

are actions being processed again?

meh, I’ll wait till the morning

also does anyone have torches or something to see in the dark?

amogus

1 Like

was anything processed last night i was busy do i didn’t go anywhere