| Accused | Voting | Votes |
|---|---|---|
| nekomancer | Nyan-chan, joycatgirl, Girlcat | 3/5 |
| CatsTMGirl | CatgirlCopvig, ChibiCat | 2/5 |
| CatgirlCopvig | purrelywholesome, Bakeneko | 2/5 |
| purrelywholesome | nekomancer | 1/5 |
| Not Voting | CatsTMGirl | 1 |
Alright
So first, an apology: although i tried to play this game to the best of my ability, my parents have recently learned what a ācatgirlā is; as such, my activity might be significantly less
Lets start with these:
First, i completely disagree with what nyan-chan is saying, althoguh this may be just a difference in philosophy. There is no hunting for ānon-jesterā plays because those dont exist, and itās more than optimal for scum to act purposely jestery as to continue living/throw off town.
But second, i want to look at nyanās interactions with CatsTm:
These two spend a good 100 posts or so arguing about something very trivial, on whether each other is the jester. I find it weird that they arent really arguing that each other is the scum, since thatās what i would expect from town. This leads me to believe that at leadt one party is pushing gor pushingās sake, thinking a heated argument will prove their towniness. Hey, the more you get called jester as scum, the better
My point still holds in that they might still be teammates, since their srgument was not around whether each other was scum, rather that each other was the jester:
āOh theyāre probably just jesterā is going to be a very common theme for scum to pull in this setup, and i see it happening here
- You could say that ānon-dogā plays donāt exist, because itās more than optimal for dogs to act purposely like cats
- Itās literally not optimal because if both dogs do that then they just get snapcuddled D4 D5 and we win
If everyone else still doesnāt think that Neko is the Jester then Iām okay with voting them out
but we really can afford to play it safe here
So like
I allow it to exist but I wonāt vote there for now
My PoE is very tight here so Iām probably being pocketed by someone u_u
Inner PoE - Neko Copvig CatsTM
Outer PoE - Nyan
Nyan is just there for the sake of reads shock and probably isnāt even actually PoE
But if the dogs donāt flip in the first set then thatās probably where Iād look first?
And then thereās Jester stuff but Iāll look at that later maybe
Hello everyone
Whoās dying 
@Bakeneko do you have a good feeling on the type of player Nyan-chan is, and just their general style
and if so do you see why I think their approach is villagery
(I think it is even minus their general style but iād expect a player of their style to have a different approach and I want to see where you are at with this)
I was busy for an extended period of time but it doesnāt seem like thread really went anywhere
I think so
no
you caught me just as i woke up 
Iād expect their approach in this case, if mafya, to be a lot more bells and whistles then seriously rusting feathers. Iād Nyanestly probably expect a similar level of antagonistic but I think the fact that thereās serious conviction behind the posts is >ryand villager. Thereās Gamer in the posts but itās backed up by something tangible
as inā¦ possibly following consensus reads?
No? Thatās nyat what I meant by bells and whistles. Iād basically expect them to be super performative if mafya without much actual substance in the forms of pushes but I donāt see that here.
Nyeh
This lack of nyactivity is concerning and I think if we donāt consolidate + pump it up for EoD shenyanigans bad things could happen, you know?
good news
i am here
bad news
neko wagon is justified after reading ISO
There needs to be some semblance of order in this game because, as it currently stands, it is super scattered.
Who I think we should kill today:
Nekomancer is fairly likely not jester when looking at these posts.
this extreme defensiveness and insistence that they are town is just not something iād expect from a jester. Possibly one thatās playing it up but considering how I think this player plays I donāt think they are nyactively attempting not to be jester-read here. Iām atleast 95% confident on this specific read, pretty far above =rand.
I think when you look at nekomancer on a macro, their posts being overwhelmingly focused on the jester is ?probably? mafia TMI leaking through. Mafia can still solve for the jester and the only time thereās ever conviction behind reads is when itās on specifically jester reads. The style of these jester reads are what iād expect to come from this kind of player when looking at mafia reads as well, but itās not really existent.
The slotās reads on mafya are all over the place and have 0 progression and 0 reasoning. I normally wouldnāt even be concerned about 0 progression and 0 reasoning but their reads have swapped around a lot. Thereās no tunnel behind it, no fire.
I think if we want to bag a mafya and put ourselves at an advantage, this is the yeet iād go for.
Who I donāt think we should kill today:
CatgirlCopvig has little to go on but I think their jester equity is reasonably high considering game events.
I donātā¦ really fucking believe this at all but I think in the world that itās fake its likelier to be jester purposefully justifying their own inactivity and slot in the PoE.
I can see reasonably how they came to the conclusion but I donāt actually think the logic holds water and has some serious holes.
This highlights the idea that they are pushing for pushingās sake, which is a reasonable thought to have, but it immediately assumes that itās because they are wolves doing theatre when, like, you could also very easily get to one of them being jester with that conclusion but that never is mentioned, which is weird because it outlined a decent premise but missed the mark when coming down to it. I find this lack of thought about the jester unsettling in that it might be TMI outright that neither are the jester. Meh.
Who else iād be happy to see die today:
CatsTMGirl is very unlikely to be jester for reasons iāve outlined. I disliked their very nitpicky pushing on NyanChan, felt decently bad faith, I gtg soon so you donāt get a wall on this one 