You might have been able to tell with my last 20-30ish posts, but if it wasn’t obvious already, I had some doubts about nekomancer that came along when I actually placed them in two frames. I’ll be honest in that I didn’t want to admit them though. I don’t like backpedalling on my conclusions
So let’s play Devil’s Advocate
Focus on the Jester?
You might notice that they worded jester before doggirls, which does seem to indicate a priority in them focusing on the jester. I do not dispute this.
This is awkwardly contradictory in a weird way, to me, I think it’s possible that nekomancer isn’t thinking about how they word their thoughts, but they are thinking about what their feelings actually are. Looking at it from a town PoV, I can see nekomancer feeling Joycat and Chibi as wolves, but lacking confidence to make a conclusion. Despite their appearance of confidence, they don’t seem to think that way.
These other points are just excitement in the verification of a conclusion they feel strongly about. I dont think it says a lot about their alignment.
The issue is, just because they feel stronger about a jester read, doesn’t mean it necessarily has to come from wolves? I can see a Town PoV from here.
Reads
The issue is, is that these reads are random, but I don’t feel like they are random in a shady way. They aren’t hoping on popular wagons. They’re changing their mind a lot, and they aren’t so much careful about how they present themselves in progression (though imo, this type of player wouldn’t have fluid progression as any alignment). The thing is that there seems to be little reason to have this bumpy of progression. They aren’t jumping on consensus wagons (until maybe a bit later on, but there’s an element of self-preservation there), but I think they sort of believe their thoughts a bit.
