I wonder if it’s possible for Aelin and Proph not to be the same alignment
reason why is because of how Liattac works. If it’s true that Liattac gives a strongman kill to the scumteam, then it must be possible that it can fall into the hands of wolves, and if it was meant to be given to Aelin/Proph then it implies that one of them is a wolf.
Not definitely, cause lol!bastard mechanics, but it’s something to think about.
a lot of people are wagoning Guillo and almost everyone has said they’re also fine with killing Wazza
I swear Guillo is still floundering with his claim, he’s doing the best he can but I really don’t think it’s believable nor is it gonna cut it
and worst case scenario, if he actually does flip town with a wagon sensor role, then town has information to work with.
i think its possible
has anyone asked them whether or not they share a card and alignment? lol
i don’t think so, it looks kinda like people just assumed they had to be the same alignment but I kind of think it might be a case where Proph is a hidden player (judging by the Erika Furudo reference) and Aelin knows that Proph exists, and can swap with him
1 Like
it’s funny because most of their reads coincide but not all of them, and I think they’re handling their reads differently too.
the Wazza situation really proves this
it looks like Aelin thinks Wazza is scummy but not enough that she 100% believes Leafia’s red
and it looks like although Proph thought Wazza was towny, he’s willing to drop his read because of Leafia’s red
and personally I think Proph would know better than to just believe the check in a bastard game
but if they’re actually different alignments, the easiest chance to catch the wolf between them is literally while Proph is on the puppet account and separated from Aelin
and I’m not actually sold enough on this to be certain.
It creates a PoE all by itself. And if, heavens forbid, it lands on a pure wagon, it clears half the village.
No.
The only world in which I can see this being true is one in which the role has more restrictions, such as only being able to check the third wagon or lower. Even so, it would be extremely strong. It’s like getting several free cop checks if you hit a pure wagon, and a free PoE if you don’t.
1 Like
I see no reason why Galena wouldn’t have used it on the Shurian wagon or something so it’s just bullshit as far as I’m concerned
a
why is Luxy trying to mechclear Aelin and Proph
mech clearing went badly in Umineko 2 because it also had bastard mechanics so I just powerwolfed on a false clear
People should make social reads here.
The problem is that most social readers have died.
commentary
Luxy doing good stuff
he might be town for trying to save whysper when she’s being poe’d by everyone else
poor guillo, holy shit
best case scenario he’s telling the truth and can just die, worst case scenario he’s trying to get people to let him survive as a wolf
looks like luxy and arctic thought the same lol
guillo went full lolcat after that and everything else is a copypasta
actually i’d buy the 3p survivor claim solely off the fact that our dvc energy vig didn’t succeed in killing him, he probably has a bpv unless as i said before, if wazza got redirected to exactly guillo.
kinda think Luxy’s readlist looks good? except maybe the Aelin/Proph thing
but Arctic is insinuating there are at least 3 mafia in there and I think there’s like, 2
why is everyone clearing Aelin/Proph or even assuming they’re the same alignment? If they’re different alignments they will endgame.
wow i don’t like proph’s readlist either
idk why proph is hanging onto this so hard when nobody else is really bringing it up anymore except maybe arctic
at least luxy came up with better reasons to TR whysper, but unfortunately she’s not been in the thread yet (?) and I’m the only one who got a message from her last night.
yes yes yes thank you Whysper
Whysper is gaming
I think whysper has kinda figured things out, or at least looks like her train of thought matches my train of thought
and i think guillo may really be a 3p survivor with a bpv that absorbed the vig shot last night