/unvote
I wasnāt doing it to be townread. And itās not exactly the same thing. Unless you are lumping anything to do with replacements as the same thing.
I didnāt know that asking a replacement to reclaim was uncouth. Iāll make sure not to do so in the future.
And Iāve already given the puppet to someone. Iām fine with hammering Guill when everyone is on board with doing so.
Is there a reason why you moved Aelin/I out of the PoE?
Yeah itās a bad thing and something that shouldnāt be done, but itās not like you would know and if you donāt ask them to claim, thatās acknowledging the existence of replacements.
There should be a lot resolving around the whole thing.
youāre town, probably
I donāt know, for some reason when your mechanical importance was revealed Iām starting to get cold feet about your slot
the premise is pretty much the same
player replaces in and shortly afterwards gives information that they would not have had access to this quickly if they were mafia
But thatās what Iām arguing against. It would be info they could have as mafia quickly. Even the fact Marshal probably would have put something in the rolecard itself. But even if not that, there is wolf chat.
And again, itās not just that. Itās also the fact that Amelia had no problem just claiming right away without hesitation. I would think theyād actually check on whether people are open claiming or something.
Additionally, with it being such a complicated role, Amelia seemed to have no trouble paraphrasing it right away when asked.
The fact that Whysper is specifically fixating on that point as opposed to talking about all of the other posts Iāve made feels like a strawman tbh
i agree with this part
thing is, they didnāt even seem to try and get cred from doing this
like prophy never said āyeah amelia is town because they knew their roleā
it looked like he was actually just trying to find out if the claim was real
this is true.
I sheeped arctic on that point (potentially Amelia being town)