Ciconia FM: Thread 1 - Day 1

[Marluxion]

The original post was you saying you are so confident in wazza scum that you can clear yuno as v by spew

why do you scumread wazza? that is the whole question

[Vulgard]

That might actually be a tell, come to think of it. “If Vulgard gets a lot of early votes, he’s a villager.”
Weirdest tell ever.

[WindwardAway]

@Vulgard

“If Vulgard gets a lot of early votes, he’s a villager.”

didn’t you get a lot of votes on D1 in that trainwreck of a game where i snapvoted Atlas?

[Marluxion]

no just me
i thunderdomed him and nobody else even voted with me

[WindwardAway]

@Vulgard

@WindwardAway

are there reasons specifically why you think triplethree not wanting Marshal as GM, or swapping reads on Wazza, is villagery? asking since Nightingale specifically thought those posts were wolfy.

I thought these posts were messy progression-wise in a villagery way. They didn’t look like predetermined conclusions, more like play by discovery, which is what I expect from villagers.

Ok, thanks, that makes sense

[Marluxion]

and then leafia pain happened

[WindwardAway]

weird, I thought I had voted with you at some point but then went off on Silviu instead

[Vulgard]

@Marluxion

why do you scumread wazza? that is the whole question

• Tonally wolfy. She’s more “chill” as a villager.
• Behaviorally wolfy. Her pushes make no sense and read more like agenda for that reason.
• Overplays the aggression card, which is what she has historically done as a wolf.
• Tries to control threadflow, which simply isn’t how she approaches the game as town.
• Her read and push on me is asinine, not because I dislike it, but because it’s logically nonsensical.

[Marluxion]

i think you were voting with me on leafia on the second day of d1

[WindwardAway]

I voted and then unvoted Leaf because I thought Silviu had TMI’d her as villa lol

[Marluxion]

yeah that sounds right

[Vulgard]

I’m not moving my vote, I want Wazza out of the game and I want it to happen today.
I can’t see people getting her out of the game later. She wins wolfgames by sheer oppression of the thread. If you don’t let her do it from the start, she won’t be able to manipulate the thread in her favor.

[Arctic]

@Vulgard

Idk, I’m reading Shurian’s ISO, and despite not having any reads in it, it seems fine on comfort and thought. It doesn’t read like someone who’s not comfortable in the thread.

he’s capable of sounding like that as both alignments
using vig10er and sfol66 as examples
difference is in sfol66 he only gave consensus takes in the form of snap reads but in vig10er he had slightly more nuance

if he doesn’t have reads it’s not a good look

[WindwardAway]

yeah maybe youre right and i didn’t keep a vote on vulgard until way later in the game, and then retracted it anyway

[Vulgard]

@Arctic

if he doesn’t have reads it’s not a good look

Agree, which is why I’m not putting a townread on the slot. I want to see actual solving.

[Arctic]

@WindwardAway

another odd thing is that I’m being wolfread specifically because I spent 4-5 hours openwolfing

Very odd indeed

[Vulgard]

I was a wagon at some point on day 1 in that game, Wind, you’re not wrong.

[Vulgard]

Nightingale can be mafia, since her only wolfread is something I strongly disagree with.
Maybe.

[Marluxion]

zone still living brings me great pain

[WindwardAway]

Shurian’s just at a null for now, cause it didn’t look like he’d read enough yet and he promised an incoming post later that I’m waiting for.