So I’m back, and I read 2/3 things I said I was gonna read
Starting with the Pointcheck:
Pointcheck analysis
Light’s tone is
Blatantly acting here.
They’re nearly implying here that Lemon is 100% scum; coming from scum, the logical progress there for anyone else would be “well Light was probably trying to set up a ML.”
But the tone is blatantly acting - it wouldn’t have been too off-point if he had said “Oh nooooo, Lemon is totally scum here, oh noooooo.” The killing blow comes when even after making this analysis, they largely ignore it and don’t even try to CFD to a near confirmed scum even when they were dying. -1 brownie points for light.
And from this, -1 brownie points for Arete: even though they acknowledged that Lemon could be scum from that, they don’t really interact with it further, even though they are top wagon (at this point they’re tied I think because of triplevote). Yet they do not CFD onto Lemon, which tells me that Arete likely knows that Lemon is scum.
And now let’s go into Damning points for each individual from EoD4. For PKR simply not existing, there’s no points on them; however, I would think them not existing contributes a tiny bit to their towniness.
Arete Damning points
depiction of the 2 pushes on “flailing around or tunneling,” showing disapproval of any pushes on Arete. Judging from the fact that Light is not a large busser (they didn’t bus Wazza D1), this would be indicative of them supporting Arete, their teammate.
Same there, buddy-buddy with Arete.
All posts quoted are activity tells ):<
Lockscum
My thing from yesterday, on them strawmanning
World building + can be seen as setting up a ML based on an inevitable outcome
Appel's Damning points
Even though they are voting light, they are still convinced that Light is indeed town
Above but a little more explicit
Same stating that Light feels towny, except putting a little distance just in case Light flips
Appel's saving points
Quick turn onto scum at EoD when they could’ve voted out Arete instead
Light never answers this, suggesting that the reasoning was TMI
Arete's saving points
Explains their own reasoning + refutes claims against them, logical explanations - point 1 and 4 is something that comes from town
The one thing from gorta I saw
Pretty good I guess since they push on Light, looking into their reads (correctly) and pointing out the mistakes from the viewpoint of a townie.
Overall I don’t think they would be aligned with Light here
fluff
Ara ara.
Results:
THE TWO REMAINING SCUM WE HAVE (yes, two) ARE LEMON AND ARETE
PKR and Gorta are almost never aligned with Light; it never benefits them to continuously distance themselves from Light D4.
Light was evidently acting (poorly) yesterday; in no world is “oops I forgot to do the check” points to their towniness. At best it points to them actually not knowing Lemon’s role; if they actually knew Lemon’s towniness, they could’ve just stayed silent, waited for town to realize that scum had stayed quiet, and had a easy ML. Furthermore, Light didn’t even try to kill Lemon even after he supposedly realized Lemon’s scumminess.
As for Arete, Light clearly opposed the lynch on them and were quite friendly. Whereas Appel had a few confused moments and was wrong, Light spent a lot of time claiming Arete was town and bringing gorta and myself down together with Arete, even though if they had joined the Arete push they would not have died.