Corrupt Votes FM - Day 6 (3/15) - Town wins by voting out town

[Arete]

my read on cloned is ‘literally never a wolf even before the nightkill’

if I’m wrong then dead chat is probably flaming me right now for not reevaluating when I’m still alive but like … all the reasons I’ve had for village reading him still apply, Light’s treatment of him and Wazza makes no sense if he’s a wolf, he’s also the only person really continuing to solve today despite the fact that if he’s scum he’s effectively already won

I think the nightkill (and more broadly, the nightkills this game in general) are more likely to come from you than from Gorta because for lack of a better way to phrase it Gorta makes very boring nightkills and the nightkills have not been boring

like, to explain what I mean, when Gorta was deciding non-PR-related nightkills in SFoL 64 he basically just suggested or ‘kill the town leaders/consensus townies/SPKs’ (or made PR-related kills
(n.b. these aren’t the kills that ended up happening but this is to give an idea of his thought process)

the nightkills this game have been solidly weird, like, Leafia was not consensus V, Lemon was literally a neut claim, and while I can speculate as to how those kills might have benefitted scum I don’t think Gorta really considers making those nightkills in the first place as scum – the Lemon kill in particular was, like, objectively the best kill for scum since it keeps cloned + me alive so he can tunnel me while also leaving {whichever one of you two is town} alive so that even if cloned reevaluates I still have a good chance of “picking wrong”, but I don’t think the possibility of killing the neut would even occur to Gorta. Maybe I’m not giving him enough credit, but.

whereas I know this is within your wolfrange, like, I can look at how you chose kills in Watch Your Mouth to see that you didn’t always just kill off the town leaders/consensus villagers but instead were much more creative with your nightkills

the obvious thing that’s making me slightly hesitant is that I’m still alive even though I’ve been tunnelling you, but I think that makes sense when considering the fact that cloned is tunnelled on me and Gorta has been Strongly Considering me, so leaving me alive in the hopes that I get miscuddled makes sense even if I’m right

[clonedcheese]

im looking at this and I’m like
how do you have access to the discord

[Arete]

because I was co-hosting

[clonedcheese]

@Appelsiini

…I meant in Wazza’s case? Confused noises

@Zone_Q11

Vote Count

Accused	Voters	Number
Wazza	Arete (1), Insanity (1), Leafia (1), Conduit (1), Trochi (1), Moleland (1)	6/8
cheese	Eli (1), PKR (1)	2/8

Eli not voting wazza
I don’t even remember Eli having a good against me other than “3p hunter bad”

[clonedcheese]

that’s the joke
im stupid

[Appelsiini]

@Arete

I think the nightkill (and more broadly, the nightkills this game in general ) are more likely to come from you than from Gorta because for lack of a better way to phrase it Gorta makes very boring nightkills and the nightkills have not been boring

What you’re failing to consider here is that this is not early game, and killing anyone else would actually be straight up unoptimal for Gorta. Cloned is tunneling you, you’re tunneling me, I’m the person everyone had next-in-line after PKR. Killing anyone but Lemon would actually be more dangerous than killing the Neut.

I need to think about the neut check thing, and how it would line up with people, but that will come later because mobile.

You’re also assuming that I was the one who made the Leafia kill, which would be right after subbing in because the day ended. The other reason is kind of angleshooty so I won’t go there. But why couldn’t my other scummates have made that kill instead?

@Arete

can look at how you chose kills in Watch Your Mouth

I feel the need to point out that those town leaders happened to be townreading me pretty hard

[Arete]

@Appelsiini

You’re also assuming that I was the one who made the Leafia kill, which would be right after subbing in because the day ended. The other reason is kind of angleshooty so I won’t go there. But why couldn’t my other scummates have made that kill instead?

I mean

I assume the Leafia kill was decided on collectively by the living wolves, and it’s possible that that was mostly Light

@Appelsiini

What you’re failing to consider here is that this is not early game, and killing anyone else would actually be straight up unoptimal for Gorta. Cloned is tunneling you, you’re tunneling me, I’m the person everyone had next-in-line after PKR. Killing anyone but Lemon would actually be more dangerous than killing the Neut.

I agree that Lemon is the nightkill that would most have benefitted scum!Gorta to make last night

I’m just not convinced that he’s a good enough wolf to realize that

[Appelsiini]

@Appelsiini

Killing anyone but Lemon would actually be more dangerous than killing the Neut.

I’m so tired
I’m gonna listen to Arete’s reply and go to sleep

[Arete]

When do you expect you’ll be back

I want you to vote first (typically in a MyLo/LyLo situation with locked votes it’s beneficial to have wolfier players vote earlier, not sure if that applies in this situation but it seems like it can’t hurt) but if you’ll be back far enough before EoD that we’ll still have time to discuss things then I’m good with waiting

[Arete]

me: ‘why do Europeans complain so much about American EoD times, they can just stay up late or set an alarm’

also me: ‘why is EoD at 3 AM, I hate everything’

[Appelsiini]

@Arete

I assume the Leafia kill was decided on collectively by the living wolves, and it’s possible that that was mostly Light

Okay. Now, do you think it’s mostly Light, or do you think it’s me?

@Arete

I’m just not convinced that he’s a good enough wolf to realize that

This is very bleh
Does Gorta have any scumgames for me to read tomorrow

[Appelsiini]

I’ll probably wake up around 6 or 7, so 8-9 hours. We got time. Now, good night.

[Arete]

yes

SFoL 64 (on Geoffrey_Bailey), “ToS” FM (Ici’s game), think there might have been one more that I’m forgetting but I’m not sure

[an_gorta_pratai]

@Appelsiini

The nightkill would make the most sense from Gorta because I townleaned him in my ISO, Arete townreads him and scumreads me, and Cloned scumreads Arete. Having Lemon die doesn’t reveal any info, so it would be a very safe choice for him, as we’re busy reading each other.

Here’s what happens if I am a wolf. I kill Cloned, push Arete, and would have the support to get rid of Arete because the NKs would look extremely bad for Arete in this situation. I don’t think we have ever been scum together, but I am a strategist. If I am framing Arete I kill Cloned. The whole thing of being a scum is pushing a narrative and making up information that supports it. The Lemon kill does not make sense from a scum!gorta world here.

@Arete

I think the nightkill (and more broadly, the nightkills this game in general ) are more likely to come from you than from Gorta because for lack of a better way to phrase it Gorta makes very boring nightkills and the nightkills have not been boring

like, to explain what I mean, when Gorta was deciding non-PR-related nightkills in SFoL 64 he basically just suggested or ‘kill the town leaders/consensus townies/SPKs’ (or made PR-related kills
(n.b. these aren’t the kills that ended up happening but this is to give an idea of his thought process)

I do play safer because it’s very easy to lynch Leafia and most of the times people won’t listen to Leafia, so why would I kill that. I take down the town leaders and try to take their place. If I can’t take their place I try to let the town go crazy and implode.

@Arete

I don’t think Gorta really considers making those nightkills in the first place as scum

I wouldn’t kill you or Appel here as scum for reasons I have stated above

@Appelsiini

and killing anyone else would actually be straight up unoptimal for Gorta.

Why wouldn’t I kill cloned and frame Arete even more? I could convince you and Lemon to vote Arete if Cloned died and I am sure of that because if Cloned was killed it looks terrible for Arete.

[an_gorta_pratai]

anyway, I am back from job stuff, so if anyone wants to talk just say so

[Arete]

I’m back

working on typing up my current thoughts but happy to try to discuss things with other people if anyone’s around

[clonedcheese]

im around
although i shouldn’t be

you can ask

[Arete]

where’s your head at

[clonedcheese]

currently at “I think it’s Appel and I think I tried enough with you to not get yelled at after game”

[clonedcheese]

at this point i think it’s not gorta
and I don’t really have time to consider that world

things from today:

@Arete

I think the nightkill (and more broadly, the nightkills this game in general ) are more likely to come from you than from Gorta because for lack of a better way to phrase it Gorta makes very boring nightkills and the nightkills have not been boring

like, to explain what I mean, when Gorta was deciding non-PR-related nightkills in SFoL 64 he basically just suggested or ‘kill the town leaders/consensus townies/SPKs’ (or made PR-related kills
(n.b. these aren’t the kills that ended up happening but this is to give an idea of his thought process)

not the best argument but has the line of logic
the initial assumption of NKA actually being useful instead of being a “who can think one more step ahead of everyone else” is wrong here
but nothing that is damning here; might be more evidence for poor reasoning to kill Appel

@Arete

the obvious thing that’s making me slightly hesitant is that I’m still alive even though I’ve been tunnelling you, but I think that makes sense when considering the fact that cloned is tunnelled on me and Gorta has been Strongly Considering me, so leaving me alive in the hopes that I get miscuddled makes sense even if I’m right

my point on above
NKA is BS because you could’ve thought all of this as scum already

Looking at past activity
Arete has consistently bussed their teammates, if they are indeed scum
Appel has done the exact opposite
…which is within both people’s scumgames
mrrrrr

@Arete

I want you to vote first (typically in a MyLo/LyLo situation with locked votes it’s beneficial to have wolfier players vote earlier, not sure if that applies in this situation but it seems like it can’t hurt)

I
dislike this