Read Astand post for why I think he was scum
Well, i see.
ill probably look at her iso too so i can form some of my own conclusions too
tbh cent and leafia being T/T isnt impossible either
thumbs up emoji, ty vul have a min cookie
If you have to ask me what I had in mind immediately after I saw Light’s post, it’s that most of the stuff are non-reads that presented as if they are in some way reads (if this makes sense)
Do you mean IIOA
(From Mafiascum)
" Information Instead of Analysis ( IIoA ) is a commonly used scumtell describing a player consistently posting summaries, setup speculation, and other content, but that doesn’t critically analyze content to actually sort players and decide on an elimination. This behavior tends to indicate mafia members attempting to look active but are failing to fake genuine scumhunting."
Rather opposite.
Question theirs reads.
Not negatively, but force them to explain them. This way they can actually reinforce theirs own opinion if it’s right, or find some contradictions.
And also it will help you think if you want to follow that person to begin with.
If you don’t want to lead own pushes, it’s fine.
That doesn’t mean being inactive.
Make friends with who you want to follow and help them reinforce theirs reads.
It’s probably way better than another person argueing for who should be lynched to begin with.
1 Like
then say why you townread that person and why you’re following them
telling people to withhold their thoughts is just as bad as forcing them to give a readslist
i’m not asking for an entire readlist, i just want people to post their thoughts so we can look at their train of thought
if someone have no opinion on anyone then it’s clear they just aren’t engaged in the game and isn’t useful if they are town
I’m Probabaly following Astand and Vul because their both not based
Unless I disagree with them
But so far I think Iv generally vibes with em
Actually just to make sure based means scum or not scum
I forget lol
yeah i really don’t think i’m feeling leafia today unless someone like
redchecks her during the day or something
i’d much rather go for someone who joined the bandwagon on her at the moment
but “not based” is a bad thing and means mafia in my dictionary in this game 
Mb y’all are both based
You don’t need people to give reads to udnerstand theirs aligment.
And not everyone is good in making reads to begin with.
You can just as well be there to help people create ideas, and the way you influence the process is enough of a hint for aligment of that person.
If you reinforce someone in idea of scum being scum, or you save a townie from badly constructed lynch, it’s just as good proof of being town as lynching scum by yourself.
Even better tbh, since you are not directly and visibly doing it (possibly for town cred), but you help others.
This is how mafia was supposed to be orginally plaied.
By cooperation, not by duel of charisma to see who pushes own PoV through.
I will say the way that Vul gets to reads sometimes confounds me, but that dosent discount said reads
centuries, i think your argument with leafia is mostly you being annoyed at her and her being annoyed at you, but that doesn’t necessarily make either of you a wolf
maybe i’m dismissing the argument too easily and you’re currently destroying me with w/w theater, but i TR you both independently at the moment anyway so whatever
lmk what you think once you read my towncase on leafia
i’m sure my reading process confuses me more than it confuses anyone else
my accuracy d1 isn’t very good but i usually get there eventually
I’ll do my best to help you get their
Vul who are you voting atm
I forget abs don’t wanna look for vc
That’s boring
I suggest voting someone playing