That does sound more straightforward. But then it means you TR Kyo? Were you already TRing Kyo before this double kill?
I’m wondering if the double kill is what makes you TR Kyo. Or if you TR Kyo first and so doubt any theory about them being NK, regardless of whether it relies on rampage or other factors.
I… I don’t know how to convince you
But if I don’t say my paranoia there’s no chance we can actually get kyo if he’s actually nk
I learned that I need to express my paranoia because I didnt do it with seth in valhalla because I pushed it away like an idiot
Vulgard, you are fitting requierments to fit one scenario.
Not trying to find scenario which fits the requierments.
That’s visible.
You are convinced Kyo is NK and try to fit your story in a way so it proves he is NK.
My question is… why?
that’s not what i’m doing
i’ve been suspicious of kyo because of the under the radar way he’s been playing and i decided to spend the night on figuring out why
an idea that he’s the nk popped up in my brain and i checked if it made any sense
turns out it does make a lot of sense
especially the pkr kill is something that only makes sense for kyo and only if he’s specifically nk
i feel like you’re glossing over individual points because you don’t like a few of the weaker ones
So apparently you want to convince me to not-yours theory, to follow Vulgard, who also expressed it today.
But apparently that’s due to having own reasons.
Min, what are your reasons (Not Vulgard’s ones) that Kyo is NK?
Mechanicly it doesn’t.
It has way higher requirements mechanically for Kyo to be NK than most other people in game.
mechanically only a select group of people can be nk and there are reasons why it’s not them
i went over that too
Whysper
Light (?)
an_gorta_pratai
TrustworthyLiberal - Almost certainly Mafia
KyoDaz
PoE of people who could be an NK, based soley the confirmability of their actions.
Let me check Light’s targets really quickly.
Mechanicly Kyo shouldn’t be NK unless they have specific abilities you fit in your scenario.
And if you add bonus abilities to the pool, then pretty much everyon can be NK to begin with.
How hes responded to being accused of nk
Him not solving like at all for the past few days
Vul expressing their paranoia made me go bonkers paranoid considering the fact I p highly tr them
rapid fire reasons
nk probably doesn’t claim roleblocker
nk probably doesn’t claim whatever gorta claimed, and if they do, they try harder to look towny instead of surviving eod 2 and mostly coasting
whysper isn’t nk because dota played like a potato and you don’t want to be in poe as nk because that invites town to use their abilities on you
tl isn’t nk because nk probably doesn’t claim watcher
although his results are not really great, but he has a similar problem to whysper being nk
Whysper is almost certainly Mafia. However, I’ve played with Dota before and I can’t rule out that they would do that as NK.
the only person in this entire game who positioned himself in the town circle, but not towny enough to be the prime target for a nightkill, who claimed a kill for towncred (the post they wrote about following gorta’s read was obviously that), and whose claim lines up with nk who wants to have a believable claim considering what their visits actually do, is kyo
