I was gonna say I suspect Meme, but your argument makes sense and I now suspect him less. I found little point in saying it after your argument.
/unvote
Back to my laptop now so able to make a full read list and also finally post this:
Here is the thing, the reads Ici has made of who scum could be could be correct, since he was the Mafia kill just now. This means that he either hit scum on the head and needed to be eliminated or Maf just thought he was a threat as a town leader who just replaced in.
If you click on my quote, you will hopefully be able to scroll up and see the colours Ici has used in order to determine Town, Maf and Cult. Within those colours, he named Nerbins and HTM as Cult. This makes me kinda sus that one of them is more than likely to be Mafia rather than Cult instead.
HTM is just using the excuse of him being a framed target for the Mafia night kill/day kill that just happened since he has admitted that he sometimes forgets to put in actions. This therefore means that not only Nerbins and Pug’s spots could be inactive, but HTM could have also forgotten it. Sometimes in other games, no other people claim that they were framed unless there is a potential Scorned, but HTM after that shot was like “OMG, I’m surprised that Ici was town” after voting him. This was suspicious. I don’t think that Mafia would actually frame HTM like that, especially trying for him to fall back under the rader after he was being to vocal and too much of a leader.
This therefore suggests that HTM is more than likely to be scum. He is more than likely to be Mafia however rather than Cult. I just can’t imagine him being a Cult member that is vocal since they only can convert up to 3 times successfully.
As well as this, HTM, you never meme this much normally when you play. You have been memeing too much with Memesky who has fallen under the rader, which actually makes me think, that you two are scum buddies and the weird memeing that you are doing towards him after he could not be bothered anymore with this game makes me highly suspicious that it’s you two.
I am pretty sure Vul/FK would have bussed Meme if he was mafia.
I would also buss Meme if mafia too. I meme like this all of time tbf…
I mean tbh I think the reason people tend to not be able to read me is because they overcomplicate things about my read, like the meme thing or me changing my plays
We have to have a lynch today if:
5 vs 5. If it is 5 vs 5 and we don’t vote anyone then we will have to hope the mafia kills a cult
We need to contribute.
Any reads on Wham? I will share mine. (We also need to focus on everyone individually not just one person for the whole day)
Wham - Town lean
Wham has contributed a lot of stuff like on the Solic wagon, he posted very townish reads, and other townie things. Though like @Nerbins’s case I don’t think you can read someone based on 55 posts and some of them could be memey not saying hes scum just saying not enough posts to = likely town.
So you read Meme and Wham as town?
Then please explain where the 5 potential scum are.
I think your reads don’t make much sense overall but oh well…
3 town in my reads so far
we have to have 5 town if we have 3 cult.
Nerb and Pug slot are the 2 suspects of the mafia
I will try to find the cult spots (if we have 3 cult) after I finish reading the rest.
There are two ways that there cannot be a cultist alive:
- Hippo tried to convert a maf n1
- Hippo tried to convert a nightkill n1
Vulgard, PKR, Squid and Marl seem to be the best converts meta-wise, if Hippo died not getting a convert off, it would likely be on one of those players. For this reason I like a policy lynch on PKR or Squid for infomation.
Town Slots:
Meme - HTM - Wham - ? - ?
Other Town Slots if cult is gone:
? - ? - ?
Cult Slots:
? - ? - ?
Mafia Slots:
Nerb - Pug
These will change as I will read others and others and reads and contributions but for now it looks like this
Tbf I was suspecting Squid of being cult/town, I doubt she is mafia due to reasons I listed but at this point in the game I think we should eliminate the mafia and then the cult.
If we kill the 2 mafia then the only way the cult will be able to out number us is by mislynching. A policy lynch on Squid/PKR is something we should do tomorrow.
I hate to be a spoilsport to your accusation.
But Hip wouldn’t convert someone overly obvious.
Everyone would suspect me to be, so it’d be the worst choice for a cult convert
Maybe that’s what Hippo would want us to think!?
Nah jk I don’t think Hippo would convert you, I do think he would convert Shuri/Squid tho (not really but I get cultish reads from them)
This is the first time someone has really mentioned Shuri.
So I find that quite interesting all of a sudden. Mind elaborating?
Squid is a bit of a wildcard flip here as are you imo. I’m thinking at least one of you is scum.
But for which one? I cannot guarantee
Well this is my theory
Shurian wanted to lynch Insanity (Marcus) and then the other day he completely didn’t want to lynch Insanity (Marcus) and wanted to lynch someone else.
My theory is that Shuri was converted by Insanity (Marcus) so he could get rid of one of his accusers. But after seeing Marcus wanting to get rid of the cult I wonder if he is cult or not 
as he should be trying as cult to find mafia to get rid of.
If cult were to convert someone it would likely be an inactive.
Insanity (Marcus) was inactive so it is likely he was converted night 1
If we get rid of the mafia then we will find out the cult easyly as well as if there are or not so the mafia should be our biggest priority
How do we think about Nerb and Pug slot being the last mafia?