Im working on it gimme a sec
Hey, I see things are getting a bit too heated and personal. A reminder that this is a game, it’s alright to take a break to cool down everyone.
1 Like
I was gonna ask alice when she got rope but she did item loggy thingy
Also I think the only time I was with alice in ch1 post alice-with-rope was in guardhouse right after she got it, which I was only in there for maybe 10 minutes.
- I could not have stolen the rope as I have a confirmed steal in Ch2 and a soft-confirmed steal in Ch1
- I would not kill Zone_Q11 as he was my ally and I have been shown not to kill my allies in miscs
- I could not have killed zone because I was low on AP, depending on the timeframe
- I could not have killed zone as I was not in shape to climb the ladder (which was host-confirmed to have had to happen)
- I made things way harder on myself Thunderdome Alice, if I was the blackened
- I would not have been able to get the blanket itself
- My low AGI would make an unnoticed ch1 alice steal incredibly improbable in itself, as I have 26 agi, which would give me only a 13% (or 3% depending on what the role calcs mean) chance of being blackened. Saying I can be lying is whatever, but my talent is basically confirmed and it’s super insane to imply that it could be above 50 agi (would have to be 60 starting because of GGhana), meaning that at most I’d have a 25% (or 6%) chance of pulling it off, at most, realistically
These are basically the “hoops” that have to be jumped through and the biggest things that should hold you back from thinking it’s me.
putting this here for later but i need to s=
@EliThePsycho Can you answer for all of these and tell me what explination you have for all of them? I understand they are not all infallible but they should at least cause serious reservation and I want to know with what degree of confidence you can dismiss each of these points.
Asked for clarification and it’s the latter
so I’d only have a 13% chance of stealing the rope with my current AGI.
-
Your steal in CH1 was never confirmed and you were in the guardhouse with me when I got the rope.
-
Again, alliances don’t mean anything here. Stop bringing shit up as you can’t rely on your word in a game of deception.
-
This relies on your kill attempt being actually sincere. I don’t think you’d actually try to kill min in public like that.
-
You were in shape to charge at me with a bat and roll after I tried smacking you. You aren’t as crippled as you make out to be.
-
Yes, now you realize this? This shit worked out to your favor in ToS2, so don’t say that thunderdoming me would always be suicide.
-
RNG is RNG. If it’s not you, then who else? Like with the current evidence if you hadn’t lied I’d believe that Light/CRich/Whysper would be my top suspects. But since you lied about the key evidence in this case being in my inventory then you’re effectively outed.
Pointing it out that most of Marshal’s entire case here boils down to “Believe me!”
-
I have low stats so I couldn’t steal the rope and kill Zone. No evidence, just believe me!
-
I had an alliance with Zone so I would never kill him. No evidence, just believe me!
-
Alice held a blanket in her private slot, which was similar to the one found in the scene of the crime. No evidence, just believe me!
Literally all the evidence here, as in the prints, the state of the knife, Zone’s last wherabouts, and what have you point to him being the Blackened while over half of his arguments for his innocent require you to trust him by default.
I mean, if you’re still unsure here then I have a very cheap bridge in Brooklyn that I’m willing to sell to you.
marshal could have easily stolen it, as once per phase means once per Daily Life + Deadly Life
im not sure but in the OP it refers to the daily life and deadly life as “phases”
i will ask apprentice