Really sorry to hear about this love. Wishing her the best of luck, no complications, and a quick recovery. <3
1 Like
Between these two post Guillotina did not post at all and Wispās only post was the following.
Whatās the reasoning behind this shift?
What exactly about Wispās post are ānot that badā? Trying to understand your reasoning if any dear. If itās NAI then how is it also ārelatively townieā. this is inconsistent.
not sure why you small fonted this post. Itās odd youāre so worried about drawing attention to yourself bud. I expect you to come up with a reasoning for why their post rubbed your the wrong way. You just randomly threw this out there but are fine with also going under the radar? Minās post havenāt really pinged me but now Iām wondering if this was distancing.
Iām new here, so I dont want to jump to conclusions, can you provide some reasoning for me beyond guts. Appreciated xoxo
I am half ass set up now and there is a few things worth mentioning:
I am not comfortable with the fact LemonFairy has 50+ posts but when I tried to think of something about that slot but basically drew a blank. With that many posts I should have some kind of anything to think of which makes me feel like they could just be actively blending and farming posts so they do not get called out as lurking. For realā¦ Just skim their Iso and consider how much content they have provided.
I get the feeling reading through Kaif that they are intentionally lurking. That there is much they think but do not say. Thats NAI for now but I want to see more from @Kaif
Guillotina has gotten a lot of attention but I seriously get Jester vibes there. The way she got all excited and self voted as the train built up while overtly refusing to give reads in a way that almost felt like she was taunting players who were asking for reasoning. I do not think we should lynch this slot and honestly, if it keeps up they could make for a good Vig target if we have one.
I am still not comfortable with Tiger but my only reason for that I overstated earlier. Small things like being willing to volunteer games felt nice and if I ignore what I still feel is questionable reasoning on the W/W issue:
[quote]Iāve played with zone before, more than a couple times.
Iām perfectly aware that he is hard to read, and personally have no clue how to really read him
But, assuming we are both mafia, if i did know how and wanted to say it this game; Iād tell him in scumchat, and then talk about it āout loudā after the fact; and then give evidence as to how I came about being able to read him like that; even after a flip from me, itād still hold weight as some sort of pocketing attempt? Maybe?
But it would have been a lot better than simply saying it during the early stages when posts are likely to be forgotten again bc itās all memeās anyways[/quote]
Overall I do not see anything else that really pings meā¦
I will try to do some proper isoās later. Still want to tinker with some stuff. Its also worth mentioning I do not quite see Zoneās play to line up with the level of suspicion he is given.
1 Like
You have some valid questions here. I feel like someone also pointed out earlier Pokemon was taking baseless stances and I can not really remember a single original point he has made. Could be mirroringā¦
I thought you used āJesterā as in āVIā. Jester is very probably considered to be a bastard role. Iāll ask OP.
6 scummies in a 21 players set up seems a bit much. Is this site known for having games hosted with so much unbalance?
Unless of course itās a team of 4 mafia and maybe two third parties, then iād believe it.
My issue is that her play does not make sense for either town or scum. Its just obstinate as fuck for no reason. With the amount of defending herself she has had to do she could have spent much less energy justā¦ giving a reason. There is a part of me that feels like this would not be a play someone would make as scum for the attention its drawing and thats kinda underscored with the self vote. I could see an argument for LHF gambit to break RVS but I do not think she thinks that way as a playerā¦
Overall If Jester is not a thing between the amount of pressure from all over and her nonsensical playās I would be between feeling she is more likely town and being fucking afraid of her living until the late game if she is. I should probably read back through her while blotting ājesterā out of my mind before giving any real kind of answer though.
3/3 teams would be an acceptable number for two mafia teams imo. They also would want to run after eachotherās tail, after all. Considering the town = 3*mafia +1 formula, we can very well be in a 16/5er. Considering this looks like rolemadness, though, I expect there to be a place for a neutral role or vigilantes somewhere.
No, this site is not known for its imbalanced setups. (Though we did have an accident involving a broken mech which resulted in a D1 NK victory once in the past.)
I am not knowledgeable when it comes to balance. I am merely stating my thoughts on the probable amount of numbers of scum in a 21āer in general.
1 Like
What is CFD?
Itās just troll behavior if not a trollish playstyle. I particularly like his boldness.
Cough
Completely not my fault.
1 Like
(Guill said heās male.)
Helz, the thing is: You are experienced when it comes to rational thinking, but you have to broaden your range and understand that some people simply refuse to play the same way you do, even if they know it is not the āoptimalā way to play the game.
I agree with your opinion though. Our version of Guill had a distinct level ofā¦ ātoneā whenever he rands town.
Oh no! I love attention. But you got a point, iād like to explore other venues and everyone else to do the same.
Chinese Fire Drill.
Essentially āa lot of people changing votes somewhen really close before EODā.
with a 21 player set up probably 4 scum, 1 indie, 16 townies.
Oh I agree. I just do not think this is a question of ārational thinkingā or āoptimal play.ā Its a conscious decision by the player to just not cooperate. Its a question of if that comes from them as a person or if its an intentional play. All we can do is throw that to the WIFOM gods.
1 Like
How come you townread me when ive been purposely scummy half the day? This cant be a real impression.