Cool. Now give me your reads on Whysper and Lemonfairy.
Not if you can start acting towny, at the very least. For starters, by giving your reads?
Or explaining how your TR on me went down all the way to upper POE, but only after I put all eyes on you?
I thought I was already acting towny
if not, then idk how to act towny
reads now are like
aelin/luk
wind/chloe
phroph/wisdom
min/nika
zone
whysper/blitz
your TR dropped after I looked at Wiisp ISO
and I thought youāve always had your eyes on me?
I honestly donāt remember who Wisdom replaced, but that is a confusing slot to place in top town and notice how Helz and Wiisp are right up there. This coupled with the fact that on Day 3 when Wind put Wisp and Helz in her scum leans, Guillotina immediately picked a huge fight with Wind and started to SR her and tear her case apart, mostly not saying why her reasoning was wrong, but instead saying that Wind wasnāt taking responsibility for her actions and blaming others instead. Which feel like attacking the person instead of the argument.
I lost the post because the page refreshed but Whysper claimed her code was 035. iirc Wiispās code was 033. Thatās awfully close. maybe it means nothing.
Doesnāt elaborate why Aelinās post are scummy and wants her to claim X-x
Whys said prior to this that she didnāt follow along but skimmed a few things. She says that something is wrong with the Wiisp wagon but doesnāt explain that beyond āWiisp is more townie than Aelinā without elaborating as to why. One could say that Wiisp was a lost cause and no scum would go out of their way to defend here, but that same logic can be exploited by scum, espcially those who do not like to buss.
I disagree. I think Wiisp played as inactive scum. I donāt remember anything remotely solvy from them and I thought they were scum for defending Tilg, but in hindsight it was white knighting. the only think Wiisp repeatedly did was sr Aelin and then say āI dont have a handle on this gameā or something to that effect. He also refused to interact with with people when he was questioned or asked to.
Also, Aelin as been anything but long winded and her post count is not exceptionally high. Thatās a big misread there that I canāt see as substantiated by fact. She only had 2 long post iirc.
Whysper also didnāt speculate who might be wolves on Wiisp wagon if he were town, and I suspect there were indeed wolves on this wagon who could be bussing Wiisp for town cred and she didnāt want to help us figure that out whatsoever. this post also threw dissent onto a well reasoned wagon and a vote that didnāt pop out of nowhere, but one that was building since day 1.
the last part is the most incriminating part. She speculates that it could be v/v but instead of trying to mitigate that and change the flow of this thunderdome, is happy with one getting lynched and keeping wiisp for his supposed helpfulness to town.
I actually like this post because I dont usually see scum admitting that they were wrong or identifying why they would seem scummy.
I like the thought process here as well, even though she was wrong on Helz; however, in retrospect it could be she was trying to save Helz and this aligns with this next post:
before this, Whsyper never sussed Lemon. I feel like Lemon was an easy vote to latch onto especially after she was cased by Proph, and the choice of words is unsettling. āpark my vote hereā feels opportunistic to me. Also, she never explained what about Lemonās interactions was scummy or even who she interacted with that made her SR Lemon. X-x The āinterestedā in Luk discovering more on Helz feels like a throw away. It looks like distancing. Especially along with this next post.
Donāt think this one requires much analysis. Iāve made my point. And unlike Chloe who had a complete shift in logic from Erika when she joined, Whysperās logic has been eerily consistent with Guillyās which makes me feel like these reads werenāt genuine, but part of an agenda/consensus made by the scum team :x
Throughout this game Whysper hasnāt given scum reads, but so far has just been really quick to town lean on scum X-x I dont think that is a coincidence. The post above is the most I can find by way of scum reads but itās really just leans which arenāt explained. When Zone (iirc) asked her for her scum leans, she basically laughed at him with a post which was something like āpffffftā and said āI donāt need to do what you askā which is fair. But whatās been asked is to scum hunt, something, you as town should have been doing already. itās not really a challenge. I think the shift to SR Helz too was just a buss. 
I think she realized Helz was a lost cause and she couldnāt risk being associated.
ah I found the post I was thinking about. It was different from what I remembered, but this is actually a bit more incriminating. She SR Helz, but doesnāt switch her vote there even though heās supposed in her PoE. Of course Zone was being a bit rude in his approach imo.
In conclusion, there are too many scum associations around this slot for it to be pure coincidence imo. And itās not just based on Whyās bad EoD actions, but also on Guillotina as well.
Vote: Whysper
Hereās my current list.
TR
Proph
Chloe
Lukundo
WWA
Aelin
TL
min
Wisdom
Mercenary
NR
Blitz
SL
Zone
Lemonfairy
Nikamara
2 Likes
dont tell me itās TLDR now
Iām pretty confident you arenāt scum. I expressed this to Luk during the night phase. I just came out of that recent game with you as wolf and I can see the difference. Also based on other past games.
1 Like
I think his reasoning has always made sense and came to a lot of the same conclusions/I agree with a lot of it which is why he is closer to the town side of my null list
*whispers* but his personality is a bit abrasive :x