bacc to answer questionaire after reading about low WiM
lets take the examples I used there
the former - you pushed nappy hard on the basis that you thought an RT was stupid and he was going to change his playstyle, when realistically neither of these are very wolfy. Im not saying they cant come from a wolf! im saying they both can, have and will come from town so that was a sucky reason to push
the latter - the post where you said ‘im trying 3 posts early’ and said Arete was both V and bad at FM -
-dinner-
so arete says ‘your wolfy because your not tunneling me’ and you take that as a reason to think their town? I dont really see how that translates
did I answer the wrong question
well its above
and I think its weak reasons for the read
those two specific examples im using because thats where I saw it
he feels less trapped or squirmy and more
‘this is absurd’
and saying why its absurd
…
what
being completely off topic is scummy because its completely off topic.
making your first(and the only read I remember) a SR on your SRer literally in a reply to them stating their read is textbook OMGUS, and the reasons Ami provided(Nappy was being overbearing) was not something I agreed with in the slightest - he was being a lot more heldback then previous games, including even his towngame in SFoL 61.5
meta was not really involved with this read
why is a narrow view scummy
…because its a narrow view? Its a thing wolves do to avoid spewing alot of people, particularly since its a smaller game
I dont have alot of meta to back this up, but I do remember Arete doing something similar with kat in FoL 28(though Arete has claimed they do this as town too, which is actually something id like to see)
ive already answered this
catching up
I rolled VT for the first time since I played mafia in the starcraft 2 arcade lobbies and the one role called ‘Judge’ villafied me
(yes I was a VT after being robbed but I was stil Zeus, effectively an IC once I claimed)
also that game was fun as heck, I strongmanned well and I was easily and always a townread for people
its easier to be town when your read that way, or at least get that impression
…oh yeah
no i was about to snap last night
sorry bout that
(I know the quoted post isnt really about that but yes)
you cant spell we without mafia
dunno the difference besides 1v4 situations where no-lynch is the best choice
…im trying to read for the question to respond to
no, I was not attempting to develop a read there, I was trying to explain where I already was
I fail to believe you dont know this is dumb
of course im not going to lock myself into reading half of the game because my opening post said id prefer to read X over Y
and I said it because I was thinking it, and it was ~prompted, and will continue to work in a similar way.
quote plz
oh and arete on Kyo
im going to defend it even if I didnt like kyo as much
that did not happen.
it just didnt
lemme explain what did happen:
Kyo says marshal prob scum for the joat softs and staying alive
Kyo ~rescinds when he seeing Mode’s too obvious softs - this might’ve not been obvious enough?
People quote the first thing, then call it wrong
Kyo talks about mafia theory
People argue mafia theory
thats what I read, anyway. It was a push that didnt last as long as the argument
I think both sides have done that but w/e
its not openwolving
but I do agree its really stupid and fully concede this
megapost or looser
/s
return of the
scumread
id like, actually, if you could provide your own reasoning, or what from my wall you consider the strongest points
getting sheeped on a read im now iffier on bad
…why are you using my posts as an argument then assuming im scum?
because I caught two fish today one of which was a keeper
because my flavor is Loaf and theyd never give that to scum
because my rolecard said so
im going to leave it to you to figure which of the above it is
This ignores what I laid out about it coming from nap specifically
I posted why I thought town!arete could have that thought, and posted (I think publicly, might have bene in teamchat) why the brashness of that reaction was specifically more town AI. Outright ignores that
Yes my reasons don’t make sense for my reads when you ignore my reasons that I post
This is meh
Like why does him thinking/saying it’s absurd make it like that. I have a similar thought and reasons but I want yours
This is the post I hate the least, it’s effectively a viberead, but I still want more.
This read is poor and arete can and has tunneled as town before, you yourself have admitted to outright ignoring the meta or not taking a look at it at least.
quote it
You were carrying and proactive and had good reads way before you had claimed. You are consistently a high poster and super proactive. I’m not going to fault you for it if it’s IRL but in games like insurgency and SFoL 61/61.5 you were much more energetic so I don’t buy the excuse that you aren’t doing well because you randed VT. You’ve been unconfirmable before, and have still been active and proactive.
I think this is a fair criticism from kat personally. You posted about how you were going to approach solving slots and didn’t follow through and said you probably wouldn’t anyways. I don’t think the thing kat pointed out is specifically AI but saying “I fail to believe you don’t know this is dumb” is super overblowing it.
Oh and one last thing
you have to be joking
You can at least look at like 2 games ever to see if this is AI. You are ignoring the counter to this already silly read.
Like you just seem to be… outright ignoring a lot of things.
You ignored that I said the bad RT was uncharacteristic of town napoleon, not town players in general
you ignored my explination for why I thought arete was townie based off of their tunneling thing. I explained it. And you just,… ignore that!
you ignore basic meta. Meta isn’t a great way to read someone but you outright ignore the existence of it when saying things are AI from people when they aren’t.
Arete can tunnel as town. At best NAI
Ami can be off-topic a ton as town. At best NAI
It’s there, you are just ignoring it!!!
Have you read all of the thread? Be completely honest.
If you haven’t read thread it’s possible you aren’t just deliberately ignoring things to make me and arete look worse and rather just didn’t see them.
I personally find it strange that you have 121 posts but haven’t read all of the thread
You have not been putting in consistent work this game
You haven’t looked for games to see if your argument is sound
You haven’t even read the whole thread!
But you present the arguments anyways with incomplete evidence and aren’t looking for context.
And while I don’t automatically hate people not reading (I don’t like it but it’s not explicitly scum AI), you’ve presented points against people that leave out important context and basically strawman indirectly (or directly)
I don’t even know what to think at this point this is so out of left field for you
I think I was gonna look at BoTF3 and then never did so i’m going to look at it again but just ahhh
tbh i hate this post, the “i dont care” attitude doesn’t get your point across, but just like shuts down conversation and makes other people get aggravated. I can sense the aggravation in this post as well. Lets remember we are all humans on the other side of the screen other than PriestessBot /s. And like keep this a more chill environment when possible and try and treat other better.