[FM] Geyde PFPs Joat9 - THE LYING DARKNESS AND FIREMAN WINS (2/2)

[Vulgard]

@Arete

I think part of why Gorta’s case didn’t work was that no part of it was remotely logically coherent

but, uh, I have an obvious bias

Because it was a tunnel. Every little thing seemed wolfy to him.

[Jane]

Vulgard, what did you think of my posts?

I feel like I succeeded in being way less performative except for like 2-3 posts.

[Vulgard]

@Vulgard

Every little thing seemed wolfy to him.

Which is why I think this is the point when you can realize you’re tunneling. When everything a person posts seems wolfy to you.

[katze]

but you’re like

a top 3 villager on this site easily

why were my posts bad

what was bad about them

i dont evern nkow why they sucked i just know they sucked

a

[Vulgard]

I think you were obvious town, so you definitely succeeded on that front.

[Marshal]

uh

1. dybudabu
2. alice
3. vulgard

nevermind he’s in

[katze]

why do you have vulgard on the list 3 times

[Vulgard]

@kat Your early posts have no direction. You’re doing several things which are completely disconnected from one another. A shitpost about Marshal there, a weaksauce push on Arete there, random questions to three random players… it doesn’t feel like you have any idea what you’re doing.

This isn’t always a wolfy trait, because wolves generally want to look like they are solving the game, but it feels more performative than useful. Especially since you’re doing that so early on in the ISO.

[Jane]

Also, Marshal, what did you think of my flavor?

[Marshal]

also another dat appreciation post

we were obvious wolf to anyone who like… read my posts or kats posts

but dat like

posted a lot and did good

dat good

[anon6348071]

Dat is indeed best bird.

[Marshal]

intimidating

seeing someone super confident on a wolfread on your slot to the point of shitposting is scary

[Vulgard]

@katze

Anyway, gonna go back to my initial plan of “post less, relax and drop reads when they come to you” that Arete interrupted by being weird.

I kind of disagree with Marshal on their “sulit V” read but they’re using meta while I’m not really aware of her meta so I’m kinda letting him have that one for now. She’s kind of null for me RN.

I’m flip flopping a bit on Arete, but I’m leaning towards them being a villager because I think wolf!Arete would be a bit more scared of our slot. Still think their thought process initially was weird , but that discussion is over

Nappy is weird and compared to prior town games of his I think there’s certainly difference

@Wazza

Dude, I’m giving you one last chance to get into the rolecard with me instead of wasting our posts in this chat being annoyed as hell. Stop ignoring me. We’re partners in this game and you’re ignoring me because you’re annoyed with the thread.

Last post I’m wasting on this.

This post (and in turn, a lot of Wazzas ISO) feels kind of performative

I know DatBird has a bit more of an obvious meta though so I’m opting to read more into his posting since I historically tunnel Wazza a lot

To which I say his posting is okay but not spectacular

Kinda thinking Centuries is a villager ATM (keep in mind I don’t really know their meta and I couldn’t find the scumgame they directed me towards on MC)

@Centuries

I read that but I’m going to act like I didn’t read it and I’m going to scumread you for it

Zero fucks attitude

@Centuries

Litlit how come you’re so happy and like motivated in this one game of forum mafia

@Centuries

Well to begin with you’re actively doing stuff

@Centuries

You’re exceeding my expectations

I don’t know if it’s in a good way or in a bad way though

Like what made you, want to play?

Now, to my understanding, sulit and Centuries have some history together (correct me if I’m wrong)

My logic here is sort of similar to why I think Arete is a villager

I think wolf!Centuries would be more hesitant to push a villager who knows them so well like this

@Centuries

I’ve never been at L-3 on this forum before this very moment I believe

This post is a bit weird though

I think most of their other posts are good though

@TheBlueElixir

I’m back

Gonna make some early reads

nappy/katshal v/v

Arete/ami are probably my top SL

Dat has very few posts but I dont like their opener(convoluted post)

Jane’s half done poking isn’t great

Gonna quote this postgame

@TheBlueElixir

When I’m on PC ill go through it all

I’ll wait for how he explains these reads before I actually make a read on TBE, I don’t think any of his other posts are super AI

@Jane

Wanna pretend we’re a hydra?

I’m probably reading too much into this but I think it’s kinda weird?

A lot of their ISO is giving me slightly weird vibes but I think my opinion is slightly OMGUS here

I feel like their push might be in bad faith but that’s not an overwhelmingly strong read

I’d move our vote, but Marshal doesn’t want me to move it quite yet.

Every single read here is a hedge. Again. It feels like you’re forcing yourself to make those reads.

[Vulgard]

At the end of the post, you express fear of moving your vote when there is no threat of anyone being yeeted because of it.

This is concern about appearances 101. Just move the damn vote. Why would Marshal care? He’s a villager too, right? Moving votes is normal.

[Vulgard]

A lot of what I’m saying is obviously in hindsight, but I’m pointing out what sticks out to me.

[Vulgard]

@Vulgard

At the end of the post, you express fear of moving your vote when there is no threat of anyone being yeeted because of it.

And it also doesn’t make sense progression-wise. Your reads are all hedges, so it would make sense for you to pressure vote people. But you’re afraid of doing that as well? How do you intend to solve the game?

[Jane]

kat

Where you trying to figure out why Arete was reading you the way they were?

[katze]

@Vulgard

@kat Your early posts have no direction. You’re doing several things which are completely disconnected from one another. A shitpost about Marshal there, a weaksauce push on Arete there, random questions to three random players… it doesn’t feel like you have any idea what you’re doing.

This isn’t always a wolfy trait, because wolves generally want to look like they are solving the game, but it feels more performative than useful. Especially since you’re doing that so early on in the ISO.

fwiw the push on arete was intentionally weak

i didn’t really care to fake a good one because i thought their logic that we were wolfy for not tunneling them 15 minutes in was absurd and i did actually think it was a RT/fake push

but i also kinda thought it was townier to just

have a meme one and appear to not care about my appearance

@Vulgard

A lot of what I’m saying is obviously in hindsight, but I’m pointing out what sticks out to me.

i still appreciate it

a few of these things i noticed after posting them (being scared to move my vote is something i kind of always do tbh, but it felt really wrong in that post in particular)

[katze]

@Jane

Where you trying to figure out why Arete was reading you the way they did?

YES IT WAS WEIRD

MY CONFUSION THERE WAS 100% GENUINE
A

[Jane]

Maybe that was what felt different then?

Like, trying to figure out why they were doing it mainly instead of trying to figure out their alignment.