It’s tiered but each tier isn’t really in order no
We must band together as villagers and work together to eradicate the scum
we can do it soldiers
Lets win this
before someone questions why I’m writing this its to try to get someone to talk because I’m bored and would like some discussion
I don’t think their thought process is consistent. Rather, I think there are gaps and jumps that I would expect from a villager explaining their natural thoughts, rather than a wolf who is trying to imitate solving.
For example, Arctic went into your ISO with a conclusion already, as is evident by their scumread on you prior to the post, along with his explanations throughout, which would under most circumstances be considered wolfy. It’s easier for wolves to case people than fake natural progression on them over time, sure, but the motivation behind their takes don’t… feel fake? I guess I just… believe that they believe their reads? Such as the portion where they believe you to be attempting to pocket them.
I will re-read Arctic shortly! I admit I am now having some little doubts as I write things out xD
For the bolded: I find that they feel almost indifferent to everything going on around them? There’s a sense of monotony that I’d more attribute to a villager. Like they simply don’t care about… anything. Though perhaps I read this as villager-esque because I find wolfing to be fun! 
I’m not sure! I think up until his most recent posts he has been quite villagery; like I ‘clicked’ with him.
Though his ‘derpclear’ gives me some pause, I’m unsure how smart it is for me to read into that! If you’re a villager, I think your take regarding his treatment of you is extremely valid, and I will admit I have liked your postings thusfar, which has made me begin to doubt Marluxion’s alignment a little! I don’t quite like how he has been towards Arctic, as well as an_gorta_pratai. I don’t know how someone could have had a wolfread on an_gorta after so few posts? I’m also puzzled by his lack of explanation for his top townread in Appel, as well as why he townreads me! I will have to refresh my brain on how he moved away from Light, as I honestly am having a hard time remembering the progression there. As I’m writing this I’m beginning to notice that I have some major qualms with him which is not good. xD
I feel like I want him to be a villager so I don’t feel dumb for how I’ve felt until now, but I don’t know if that’s the reality!
So, at this point in the game would you vote him with me?
Or do you have others you’d prefer to vote atm
Sure!
I currently have no better ideas. I would like to get content out of an_gorta_pratai to get a read there, but I’m unsure how useful my vote will be xD
/vote Marluxion @EliThePsycho @Intensify
Yes please!
I’m not sure how you view him as an IC! 
Intensify what are you talking abo- I mean, Votecount
| Voted | Voters | Count |
|---|---|---|
| SirDerpsAlot | Shurian | 1/6 |
| Shurian | Light | 1/6 |
| Light | Appelsiini | 1/6 |
| ArcticXI | Marluxion | 1/6 |
| Marluxion | SirDerpsAlot, illumin8 | 2/6 |
| No Vote | Gorta, Jane, ArcticXI, min | 4 |
Ping us for any missed votes
Focusing specifically on the last quote here. This is a very natural thought from gorta
This thought only comes from V gorta. A wolf wouldn’t want to clear someone for something this, and would put more thought into the read.
I know it doesn’t seem like a lot but gorta tends to have a very clear thought process as a villager. I know it pretty well in part from hydraing with them a good few times so I’m not going to like part of this read is gonna have to be a faith read. If you don’t trust me on that its fine but regardless I don’t think anyone should be viewing gorta as a wolf at the moment.
If this is something unique to Gorta then I can accept this as valid reasoning, yeah! I remember Appelsiini describing him as what I’d consider a Level-1 wolf, so I can see where you’re coming from in that he probably wouldn’t clear someone like this as a wolf, if that’s true. To be fully honest, I didn’t see the second quote you replied in my time catching up, and I think him solving the game around himself is kind of villagery, actually!
Thank you!
U know
I’ve been back for a month and have no idea how people read people sometimes (Chloe getting scumread in Umineko… Marl getting sussed in Quantum… etc etc.)
I’ve followed along before and it usually ended terribly so (in my experience thus far anyway)
I urge you to formulate your own opinions of the players in question yourself, it also gauges as a good standing opportunity to let those players see the view of strangers trying to read them in a fresh new light.
Also, I may be cryptic, but I like to think I can back up most of what I do
And if I don’t… well, let’s just say I try to make the best of the situation I can
Hi Derps