[FM] Lord of the Rings Forum Mafia - (7/25) - Completed - Mafia Wins!

[Icibalus]

There’s probably 6 wolves and a lost wolf assuming the general rule of 25% wolves.

[Emilia]

@Arete

. I’m liking Datbird’s solviness here, it feels pretty genuine to me

Where is this solviness

@Arete

and this is more of a personal thing but I like how he’s putting in effort specifically to help Andrej and the other newbies improve their reads, which I unironically think is town AI because (a) it means the newbies have better reads and are more likely to catch scum, and (b) it makes them harder to mislynch

Because Its a no effort interaction that can give towncread

@Arete

Dat’s also one of the few people here who I’ve been on a scumteam with, and on a gut-read level he’s not really acting like he did in Short Fuse.

How do you think he acted in short fuse

[Arete]

Replying to this so I don’t forget to answer it tomorrow morning, when I have actually slept.

[Emilia]

wheres your vote

[Arete]

On Astand

[Icibalus]

@Arete

Datbird: Townlean. I’m liking Datbird’s solviness here, it feels pretty genuine to me, and this is more of a personal thing but I like how he’s putting in effort specifically to help Andrej and the other newbies improve their reads, which I unironically think is town AI because (a) it means the newbies have better reads and are more likely to catch scum, and (b) it makes them harder to mislynch, like, unless literally all of the newbies somehow rolled scum, which is ridiculously unlikely, I’m not seeing scum motivation there. Dat’s also one of the few people here who I’ve been on a scumteam with, and on a gut-read level he’s not really acting like he did in Short Fuse.

DatBird this game is kind of in-meta with his wolfgame here, but I feel like this solveyness you’re getting from him is villagery even if it’s within his wolfrange.

[astand]

@Arete

She also has strong associations with Alice, who I’m scumreading even more strongly.

I am he, and p. sure the Alice read is completely pointless at this moment.

[Emilia]

He started with solviness in start (not pushing kind of solviness but kind of ones he had in short fuse) And later his activity dropped

[Boss110]

You can confirm youself as a healer at least, but yeah, not confirmed town

@Emilia

Why would you bleed when you can just not bleed And still claim it

Tracker/Lookout?

[astand]

Vulgard made a smooth post, I admit.

[Icibalus]

Arete’s wallpost is pretty good, honestly. I won’t jot them down as a villager from it but as a general rule, if a Level 2-ish player makes quite a long readlist and the readslist is actually intelligible (accuracy being secondary, but I like quite a few of the reads there) then it probably comes from a villager (unless something overturns that).

so yeah
not saying I agree with those reads but quite a few of them are good enough to get a free villagelean for effort

[Emilia]

You can still target that player even when they arent bleeding

[Boss110]

Maybe they are doing it for dramatic effect, I don’t know. Do you think a town member bleed Derp?

[Emilia]

No

[Vulgard]

I’m analyzing the people who wanted to lynch me and the people who defended me right now, and in the end I think they’re all town. I totally get why somebody would want to lynch me right away for what I did - I fell right into that reaction test thinking Alice was scum when it was a test. I totally get people defending me too, however - I was tunneling really hard there. I don’t think scum would ever need to whiteknight me in this situation. I don’t believe I’m easy to pocket (or I like to think that’s the case), so if either Marshal/Arete is scum and whiteknighted me there, I’m going to be legitimately surprised. They would benefit from my lynch if they’re scum, so they absolutely should be pushing me without question.

Basically, right now I believe Alice/FK/Marshal/Arete are all town after that reaction test and how they acted following my deathtunnel. There might be scum among them but I think the chances of that are slim.

[astand]

May be the case, which would make me sad as I thought me being in shitpost mode makes me obvious town.

This works for Hja.

[Emilia]

Because they would just claim bleed And waste town healer

[Boss110]

So why would scum bleed Derp then?

[Emilia]

I dont think his bleed is true

[Boss110]

So is he town faking bleed or scum faking bleed?