[FM] Lord of the Rings Forum Mafia - (7/25) - Completed - Mafia Wins!

False dichotomy bro

1 Like

Derps being bled comes as an astounding surprise to me and I wonder if he’s faking it. He’s probably not though - he has not been drawing attention to himself, so I don’t see why he would suddenly feel the need to do that with a bleed claim. In theory it could be an obvious play, maybe even a reaction test… I don’t know, it just feels off for him to lie about that regardless of his alignment, especially considering the timing. I was the focus, not him. What is he trying to accomplish? Towncred? Saving me? I’m not sure. It feels bizarre. Either he is a lolwolf for doing this or town.

Good question Why wont you tell me

Why won’t you answer me?

What, why would this thought even occur to you.

1 Like

did the bleed happen before map was chosen or after

After, probably

Why wont you

I mean I was the first one to ask you

And I was Second to ask So it would be logical if I answered Second too

I don’t know, I’m trying to find reasons and there are only three things that come to mind.

  1. Trying to save me for whatever reason. Again, I don’t know why he would do this as scum. Although I don’t know why he would do this as town, either. Even if he wanted to, he could’ve done it very differently. This is definitely the weakest reason of the three.
  2. Towncred. This one works better if he’s scum, doesn’t work at all if he’s town. Also, if he’s scum this is a very strange moment for a bid for towncred. The lack of awareness doesn’t read as scum to me.
  3. He really did get bled. I think this one is the most likely, no matter how weird bleeding Derps is.

Ugh
I think the bleed is true. Obviously it’s hella weird for him to just assumed Arete did it (But it’s probably some kind of joke I don’t understand). I wouldn’t be surprised if scum bleed Derp just to put suspicious on him, I mean, who would bleed Derp? Obviously that seem out of possibility here and people will think Derp is faking it. So what I am trying to say is, scum bleed Derp to get him mislynch or at least put suspicious on him and even if it doesn’t work he will just died from bleeding, or worse case a town member heal him

They bypass healing on this map So I dont see Why they would care about TH positioning

No matter who gets poisoned-
okay Hja thanks for saying it for me.

It’s only work during the night?

Yes

And So do heals And most of the kills

And theory is less likely that he is just LW Who claimed bleed as signal

I don’t think bleed can bypass healing because it only work tonight and according to Derp he will died in next 2 night

Healing bleeds should work tonight anyway, but it’s probably irrelevant.