This entire post is an interesting take. In my opinion Solic was much scummier when the day began, and became less scummy as it went on. You think it’s the other way around and he switched his playstyle a little after being suspected.
The problem is I’m not sure if Solic gets this defensive as scum. Defensiveness can be read as both scummy and towny depending on the individual. I’m not sure if either of us knows Solic’s scum meta at all.
If I’m not including meta whatsoever in my read, I think Solic is scum and I’m inclined to agree with your take on his later posting. If Solic’s town meta is exactly that - overeager attempts to dismiss scumreads on him, LAMIST (Look At Me, I’m So Town), etc. - then he might be town. Then again. He might be replicating his town game.
This is just going to make me go in circles. I still think Solic is likely to flip scum based on his entrance. Not sure how to read his behavior during the reaction test - the fact he wasn’t interested whatsoever is weird. He was scumreading me before, why is he not saying anything now?