[FM] Mafia Academy 1 - Mafia Victory

[astand]

What did your role do?

[Geyde]

Sheep me and you can’t kill me

[Maxwell]

@Kirefitten
Any chance we’ll ever get LM2?

[Solic]

What’s that?

[Maxwell]

Luigi’s Mansion FM 2

[Arete]

@Arete

I’m going to pull another Geyde here and say that this read is probably correct. Since he posted it a couple hours ago, just about no one has engaged with it in either direction; if Dat were town, I would expect some proportion of the scumteam to jump on it as an easy push unless they’re very confident in being able to pull off a mislynch, which just seems really unlikely to me unless all the wagons are V.

This read was actually good

should I just sheep Geyde every match

[Geyde]

this part in thread was wack

[Maxwell]

U should do it @Kirefitten
To commemorate the release of Luigi’s Mansion 3

[Vulgard]

@Maxwell

I feel bad for vul
He’s a solid town player but it always seems that as town, he’s getting fucked over by factors outside of his own control.

Would you mind elaborating?

[Geyde]

sorry again dat

[Maxwell]

In SFoL 53: Syndicate was ridiculously overpowered and my play was so utterly trash that I deserved to be tunneled to hell.
In SFoL 56, you had Isaac.
In this game, you forgot to out to me when I said your N1 feedback which was an honest mistake, and then I got completely bamboozled with my night 2 feedback and then got modkilled. If I wasn’t modkilled town might have won but then again maybe not since I was so fooled on Astand.

[Vulgard]

@Vulgard

I honestly did want to lynch Astand at nighttime and I still do. The lack of a death is puzzling. I feel like maybe we have to kill off Astand if we want the game to end. If there were 6 mafia, 11 town and 1 neutral, this setup is insanely scumsided at a glance.

AAAAARRRRGGGGGGGHHHHHH.

[Vulgard]

i’m just screaming don’t mind me

[astand]

Part of the reason I hurried to deflect to Nerbins.

[eevee]

Some of you already got some information mid-game about how theirs actions could’ve been improved.

So I would like to ask you general questions first.

Wallposts or a lot of short iddle chatter posts? Pros and cons of both?
Proxy votes, lack of pressure tool or trap for scum?

Also, did double-edged or deeper roles which were in this game actually made you think more about your actions?

[Vulgard]

I’ve just realized I think I was the only person alive who still wanted to lynch astand until almost the very end of the game.

[Geyde]

@Maxwell

In SFoL 53: Syndicate was ridiculously overpowered and my play was so utterly trash that I deserved to be tunneled to hell.

to be entirely fair
4 town kp went on town

[astand]

@eevee-sama

Proxy votes, lack of pressure tool or trap for scum?

Difficult to say, as only D1 had meaningful wagons, but what’s true is that I personally underestimated how many people were voting PKR.

[astand]

So me being on Nerbins wagon was meaningless and looked bad.

[Vulgard]

I feel like wallposts help make my thoughts more coherent but don’t make my reads on people better by any means. Besides, they require effort and they are a problem if I want to interact with someone (because lolpostrestrictions). So in the end, wallposts bad I think.

Proxy votes are an interesting case; I honestly don’t know if they’re good for town or not. I’m leaning toward ‘bad for town’ because they mean we can only do VCA after a lynch. On the other hand though, we can’t get paranoid over VCA until lynch.
I think they’re detrimental to town but not as much as the wallpost-centric PR thing.

The roles in this game were very interesting. Did my role make me think more about my actions? My role confused me and I had no idea what to do with it, clearly. I’m just bad at mechanics, so I suppose it would’ve been the same no matter which role I got.