I assume they were like cleaned
Hi. Weāre reevaluating briefly, mainly because of the NK. In the meantime, Iād like to hear from @MaximusPrime.
I assume this is something lost in translation; Iām talking about Jakeās death, not a neutral killing role. Obviously Arete and I were thinking hard about Jake being in the PoE, so weāre running through something right now.
Used my ability on Arete/Disquieted last night
I got one result; it was:
Yes
Alright.
Hereās the deal: if you have nothing to do, read MaximusPrimeās posts and tell me what you think of his alignment. Yesterday was a quiet day cause the lynch was obvious. Today, not so much. So letās start talking about this.
Completely baffling nightkill.
Also lol Mercās flip was cleaned.
I have a feeling the PoE is blatantly incorrect. I need to re-eval. Jake flipping town is pretty important. Maybe we really did have w/w wagons on D1.
Also my post restriction went even further down, so have fun with that.
I would still lynch Maxwell but right now Iām not so sure. Also I have to look at Arete/Disquieted again.
Maxwell is a Mafia Godfather Rolecop
Am I supposed to believe this or something? Why me? No one even took notice of me in my absence, and am I supposed to take note of this as real?
Who targeted him, and stuck whatever thing on me?
Retrospective votecounts:
(according to flips)
Day 1:
PKRiestess (6): Geyxy, Derps, Simon, Marshal, Nerbins, Aretted
Nerbins (4): Jake, Maxwell, Astand, PKRiestess
Kai (2): Mercenary, Shurian
Aretted (2): PoisonedVulgard, FireKatze
Marshal (1): Kai
Jgoesemist (1): Maximus
Day 2:
FireKatze (9): Astand, PoisonedVulgard, Geyxy, Jake, Derps, Nerbins, Maximus, Aretted, Maxwell
Mercenary (4): Kai, Simon, FireKatze, DatBird
Geyxy (1): Shurian
Day 3:
Mercenary (7): Maxwell, Astand, Aretted, PoisonedVulgard, Nerbins, Simon, DatBird
Okay. What I gather from this is that:
- Some people have potentially not voted scum the entire game. Those people include: Shurian, Maximus. They were independently town to me before, but now Iām not so sure. Three days and they were always on town wagons if we assume all flips were true. They also did not vote Merc on day 3, although that matters less since Merc was always getting lynched. There wasnāt even a counterwagon.
- Arete/Disquieted have voted on every single top wagon. The problem is that they were late voters on each of them except Merc. Maybe Iām reading into something that isnāt there, though.
- Nerbins has also voted on every single top wagon and I have no idea what to think about this. Weāve had a cleaned flip, a town flip and a scum flip, so itās hard for me to analyze why that might be the case.
- Simonās votes look really good. Early vote on PKRiestess, pushing the potential scum wagon on the day when we lynched town (early voter on that wagon too), and also voted Merc on D3. I think heās cleared town based on his votes alone.
- Derps has mostly just been voting top wagons and his votes do not seem very relevant. I want to call him town for this, but the way heās been playing until now prevents me from doing that. I want to see more from him.
- Astand has been pushing a ton. He has been a very early voter on multiple wagons. While I do still think heās town-motivated, we probably shouldnāt trust him nearly as much as before. We might have misread him and heās just mafia pushing agenda while claiming neutral. Notice how he didnāt vote scum D1 (unless Nerbins is W) and started a town wagon on D2. Based on votes alone, this looks extremely bad.
- DatBirdās votes have been oddly tentative this game. He is a late voter on multiple wagons and I feel like this lack of confidence is scum indicative for him. If only Merc wasnāt cleaned, he would be confirmed scum to me (unless Merc was town). Either way, I think he has enough wolf equity for me to lynch him.
- Maxwellās votes look really weird. Early voter on Nerbins, late voter on FireKatze, super early voter on Merc. I have no idea what this means. He didnāt vote confirmed scum (unless Merc was scum), and if Merc was scum, this could have been a bussing vote since Merc was always dying that day. His votes on town wagons were fairly tentative (I do understand that he was the second voter on Nerbins, but since PKRiestess was voting there, itās possible it was a scum concerted effort). His vote on the cleaned flip was very confident. I feel like itās scum indicative for him but I need input from someone else to solidify this read.
Based on votes, I think:
Shurian and Maximus have to be looked at.
Arete/Disquieted also, but I have no idea what to look for so please help me townies.
We absolutely need to solve Nerbinsā alignment, I think itās crucial to solving the game.
Astand looks much worse if we look at votes alone. I know he claimed neutral, but his votes are still really bad in hindsight.
DatBird and Maxwell look bad based on their votes and theyāve already looked bad independently. I think I would lynch there today if we donāt figure out anything better. I know that I said āooOoOOoOO the PoE is probably badā, but upon re-evaluating I still think these two contain at least one scum.
Based on process of elimination, I thinkā¦ well. I think I donāt have anyone I can trust. Iām starting to think a lot of my earlier reads were wrong. I need townreads instead of scumreads.
Please clear thyselves for me.
Speaking of Nerbinsā alignment, I think lynching Maxwell today spews Nerbins as V if Maxwell is W. There is no way two wolves voted on a third wolf as a counterwagon to a wolf wagon.
And if Maxwell flips town, then Nerbins starts to look much worse. Basically, a Maxwell lynch gives us important info from my POV.
Iām open to other ideas though. I think Iāve said everything I want to say at the moment. Since my post restriction is even moreā¦ restrictive now, I think Iāll refrain from posting until I see more content.
Am I the only person who still wants to play this game? And my post restriction is probably one of the worst in comparison to the other players alive. I should be the one unmotivated.
Well, anyway. Please give me material. Pretty please.
Fine. What do you want to do? Have you caught up on the thread at all? Do you have anything substantial to say? Your slot has generally been townread but it can change.
Read up on the thread and not talk too much in one day.
Not had chance too, well I have today but yesterday I was on a 278 mile car drive when I replaced in so I had no opportunity. Planning on reading later but we all know I probably wonāt. It doesnāt seem that hard though.
I would have, but Maxwell had already outed something important that I had to say, so not right now. Tonight I might but I doubt it.
One thing I do want to know is.
@Vulgard @PoisonedSquid
@Arete @disquieted
@Simon
Have any of you outed your class at all? Donāt tell me what it is, I just need it for knowledge.
No, Vulgard and I havenāt outted our class and I donāt think weāre planning on doing so anytime soon
1 Like