You didnt want to vote geyde since you scumread me. So why not just vote ME. Youre scum
If you arenât willing to reevaluate we arenât going to get anything done.
James is not scum since they used the hardclaim to clear themselves. The sequence was a townslip into a scum hardclaim into backpedaling on it all.
Scum donât do something that inhumanly weird.
Scum are logical.
This is fundamentally why the wagon on James doesnât work; itâs built up on the notion that the claim actually makes sense from scum pov.
Iâm not even assuming optimal play.
Itâs a nearly impossible sequence for scum to do unless they knew they were screwed; even then they would duck out of thread instead.
The Magnus wagon is mostly motivated by the sheer terribleness of his push on James and his responses to Marcusâs questioningâŚexisting for lack of a better term.
Magnus isnât scum because theyâve actually been looking at things trying to read other players.
Their reasoning is incredibly flawed but they are actually trying to scumhunt/
Itâs like hoping the target wonât die when pointing a gun directly at them and firing 8 times.
Sure, it might work sometimes. But most of the time it just kills you.
Moreover, no central reason unites the wagon on them.
Generally when there is no central reason or idea that pushes a wagon it almost always flips villa.
In this case it will flip villa since there is no central reason alongside the other points I mentioined.
Baz - Continues to push a point that doesnât work to the point of extremity. You could say itâs gutâŚno. I think that the slot will resolve itself if we ever flip a wolf at any point.
Marcus - Bizarre tonal plays and progression between reading Geyde and reading players like James doesnât make sense. Their group think is flawed and their tunneling hasnât been helping either. Tone while pushing me was markedly similar to how scum push in tunnels (ideally ignoring literally everything in the middle of what I was saying and not rereading the thread when I told them that was the answer).
Htm - Only contribution to thread was pushing a villager without adding on any new or interesting points. Plays the game of not reading the entire thread when they have replied to later posts in thread. Htm is my pick for most likely scum considering their apparent lack of actual town motivation; they only have put thought into defending themselves and pushing James. Quintissential obvscum by motivation.
These are all very valid votes at this point in time since PKR is self resolving.
If you need more convincing:
For being near LHF Htm hasnât been dealt his fair share of shade over the course of the game.
No wagon on Htm has stuck since the start of the game
They havenât introduced a unique point on the James wagon that actually makes it more compelling
They havenât made a single townread.