also I’m copypasting this from the off-site website where I wrote these logs, not from my role PM, for the record
Arete the Blood Mage
D1 - Collect blood from Dry
N1 - no action
D2 - Drain blood from Vulgard, Alice, and katze
N2 - Elixir of Blood
if you have any doubts that I actually wrote these/my flip might have been altered: in MHA Mafia on Mafia 451, Firekitten was able to confirm Seth as town because of the specific flavor (being pulled by the hair) used in his neighborizer, sulit and Seth can both confirm this, are the only ones as far as I know who can confirm this, and wouldn’t be able to fake my writing style
If I died that means one of two things: either Kyo chose Offensives as his type to occupy for the ritual (which would bypass immunities, so I think it would override my elixir) or that Dry ON D1/Vul/Alice/katze contains a minimum of 1 wolf
also I really should’ve made Italy one of my drain targets, not sure why I didn’t do that to be honest
killing me is really weird here when basically everyone scumreads me or scumreads me conditional on Amelia flipping town, I would look into who’s likely to do that. I don’t see Vul/Alice as ever killing me here, Alice IIRC decides night kills based on either clearing voices to suspect her (which I wasn’t doing) or being consensus town. katze I can see maybe doing it for the memes?? I guess?? and Marshal I could see for the same reason + me starting to suspect him, or Wazza for me vocally pushing him?? but overall this is a really weird kill. also possible that an Enchanter debbed someone into me, although in that case they’ll probably … out that information …
anyways my reads have been really bad this game, by PoE Amelia should have always been scum and she flipped town, so I either miscleared someone or was wrong about some of the interactions between people in the PoE as being never W/W (or both) so I’m going to try to reevaluate as many of them tonight as I can
edited to add: I didn’t make it through all of them but I hope what I did make it through helped, good luck, I believe in you
Wazza: I think this slot is a good candidate for person-I-miscleared. I basically slotted it into a town box on D1 for the town PoV slip and never reevaluated; I’m not 100 percent on this read but I’m not willing to treat this as locktown anymore. A lot of the things he’s done are consistent with a wolf of Wazza’s skill level, like, a lot of his posts are IIOA and he has a very narrow view of the game, also despite claiming to be confident the top wagons both days were town he didn’t put much effort into trying to switch to a different wagon, like, he claimed to be fine with either me or Apprentice being lynched yesterday and confident Amelia was town but had to be forced to vote Apprentice when that should have been a pretty obvious decision based on wagon formation at EoD. There are still some things holding me back – the town PoV slip on D1 is one, and honestly I don’t see Wazza as scum spending all of D2 softing Traitor, then complaining about getting townread despite the traitor softs UNLESS he’s actually Traitor and trying to signal. Just, I’m not willing to lock him as town the way I was before.
Marshal: I was having a lot of doubts yesterday despite TRing this slot D1, which is part of why I stuck with the Amelia wagon even when I was having doubts, but I think his EoD2 was really really good, like, as scum Marshal has no need to care about whether or not Amelia gets lynched and he clearly cared a lot. That on its own isn’t unfakeable for Marshal’s skill level, but based on his pushes I also have to believe that all of Apprentice, Amelia, and Seth are villagers as of EoD2, which … I don’t, really, to be honest. I vaguely remember thinking this slot had some traitor equity yesterday but I don’t remember why, and honestly his EoD2 doesn’t really make sense for uninformed scum unless he was secretly really scumreading Amelia and also my reads pre-N2 sucked, so.
Edit while reading Ici/Derps: him pushing the CFD onto Kyo is a kind of meh look specifically because of how he did it (saying he would only switch if X other people also publically announced a switch), also I remembered why I thought he had traitor equity (it’s because of Apprentice’s check if Apprentice is real)
Icibalus: I suck at reading Derps so instead I’m going to focus on Ici. loltownslips but I don’t really see Ici trying to fake the whole thing where he made a read on Kyo even though Kyo was dead and flipped scum. He’s had some weird tone things but I think that’s just his personality. Also honestly I don’t see him (this is about Derps now not Ici) trying to CFD off of Kyo as particularly scum motivated, like, if you’re reading this I’m literally flipped town and he was trying to CFD to me over Kyo, I re-read the D2 ritual part and it didn’t feel super coordinated with Kyo?? I see katze’s arguments here with the peek thing and they make sense to me but
Alice: ugh it’s like 45 minutes before EoN and Alice is hard to read
I’m going to skip her and I’ll come back later if I have time
actually I’m going to skip ahead to talking about App and DryBones because I have actual serious things to say about them that have already occurred to me, then go back and do everyone else
Apprentice: I thought about it again and I’m back to scumreading him, I think, despite saying he was wolfy Kyo never voted him afaict, which looks bad on associations, and also his 3-person redcheck thing is literally exactly a play that Kyo’s made before so it’s super plausible that he would get the idea from Kyo. Also Braixen/katze/Marshal are all just townier than him it’s going to turn out that I’ve been pocketed all game isn’t it
I’m soulreading the ‘my flip will be a meme’ thing as legit but I don’t know if it overrides everything else about him
DryBones: this slot was super obvtown on D1 and D2 pre-ritual, it stopped being super obvtown after the ritual, like I said yesterday I think it has high convert equity. I don’t know who would seriously convert DryBones but I think he’s converted. could point to people-who-haven’t-played-with-him-before? which would exclude me/Marshal/Alice/sulit/Wisp I think, maybe some others that I’m forgetting about. anyways this can die unless he switches back to his obvious town meta
anyways I said what I wanted to say about them, back to down-the-list
Napoleon/an_gorta: aaa why does Nappy have 704 posts in topic. I don’t have time to read all of these, maybe if I’m alive tomorrow I can read them, until then I’m going to stick with the probably not W/W with Kyo read I had yesterday even though I should be trying to reevaluate. okay good an_gorta only has 182, let’s look at those. 5717 feels decent because he’s pushing App specifically as Sorc? my brain thinks it would be weird for scum to push someone as specifically Sorc when they have TMI that Kyo is Sorc. him thinking his slot is wolfy is kind of 
but other than that his posts are gut-townie?? also I just remembered Nappy trying to get himself checked by Italy, which (a) doesn’t really make sense for scum to do (although lolWifoM) and (b) makes a lot of sense from the PoV of the class he’s claiming, which was a perspective he’s had issues faking as scum in the past
I suck at reevaluation apparently, I TR’d him before and I TR him now
okay I’m going to send these in and keep writing, hopefully I’ll be able to update them again before EoN, I have like 25 minutes until it ends, that should be time to talk about a couple more people although not to read their Isos
katze is next
yeah no I’m not reading all several thousand posts of hers, realistically I can’t with how much time I have left, I’m just going to give some vague impressions of her slot from what I remember
katze: I remember thinking her perspective was townie on D1, which is a decent look for her, I guess, other than that the things I specifically remember from her were her really wanting to be checked by Italy, which I think is a good look for her (obviously doesn’t exclude traitor but), like, scum can do that kind of thing for WifoM but she was pretty insistent. the thing that I feel weirdest about is her handling of my slot? like, ‘let’s lynch Arete in semi-MyLo so that if they’re town we know their reads come from town’ is a really bad take. also technically she’s thunderdomed with Braix/Marshal/Apprentice and if you’re reading this with D1!Dry/Alice/Vulgard. I think she’s the second towniest in the first group and third towniest in the second group.
next is me
next is Italy but he’s dead
okay next is Braixen
honestly I’m not reading anyone’s posts anymore, just trying to remember why I read them the way I read them and seeing if I still believe it
Braixen: I’m going to be honest I should be properly reevaluating but I don’t think I’m ever going to see his plays D1/early D2 as coming from scum, like, what sort of wolf makes a bunch of RNG readlists, proudly posts the readlists, then when people interact with them about it is like ‘haha epic scum bait I caught you, sucks to suck,’ like I’m not going to say he’s playing well but he’s playing villagery, plus then on D2 there’s the thing where he spent several hours insulting me and then being like ‘okay I guess Arete is town,’ like, I don’t want to believe he’s doing that as a wolf
already talked about DryBones
sulit is next
sulit has a confirmed roleblock which is a decent look for her (technically could be W/W with Vul but that would make Vul a wolf and I don’t want to believe that Vul’s a wolf), could technically also be from Kyo with her just claiming it? but ehhh, it’s a villagery roleblock target and that counts for something. other than that, uhhh … I think she usually converts me or Wisp and neither of us is converted, could maybe see her going katze/Alice though
oh right also I just remembered katze’s ‘if I were scum I’d convert Arete’ comment, not 100 percent sure I believe it but I believe it enough to give him some townpoints for me not being converted
anyways back to sulit
I initially read her interactions with Kyo early on as never W/W but I’m not sure if I believe that anymore, I could kind of see W!Kyo pushing on a partner like that, her posts feel basically decent? where by that I mean her first several, I didn’t read all of them. aaaa but I suck at reading sulit
honestly have some people who don’t suck at reading sulit read her, they’ll do better than Panicked Arete 10 Minutes Before EoN and they can’t possibly all be wolves, right?
Vulgard: okay I’m going to open up Vul’s Iso and count how many posts it takes to get to one that was Written By A Villager. uhh based on the RB he has to be either Seer or town or scum with sulit. anyways.
his 12th post (7436) was written by a villager, which is a decent look. uh 7510 and 7521 seem to contradict each other, someone who’s alive should ask him about that probably. also about why he voteparked Amelia before EoD despite the fact that I was the one pushing the wagon. …is he actually a wolf this game? anyways 7527 was also written by a villager probably. so is 7641. this is a lower density of posts-written-by-villagers than I would like but I’m going to call it good enough, I guess. at the very least there are better lynches.
oh wait that’s actually everyone because I aleady did Apprentice
okay
App/Drybones would be my top lynches today, Drybones specifically because he’s a convert
sacrifice someone who’s not a wolf, if there’s a greenpeek that’s a good choice
don’t automatically trust redchecks, it’s LyLo
uh
traitor rituals are less bad than they sound? since they take away a wolf vote? although Lamb is really bad
good luck
9:50 PM now, going to send these in
unfortunately this is probably just a willager but if this is wolf im gonna be very angry
