You voted for 1 of the 4 blood mage claims. You knew that you were one of them.
You knew that Seth and Apprentice were most likely legit, so you thought it was a 50%/50% Kyo was scum.
Potential that you visited them and learned they were a heretic
Notes from this:
From this chart I think I can come to the assumption that Alice is The Shaman
Would line up with by belief in them softing that they can target 2 people