Both wallposts
Aelin:
Wazza - They have a mixture of memes and reads, however their fixation on Marshal and Gorta is questionable, to say the least. Individual posts provide merit, however. - Null
N.1 - Despite posting, they have not said anything of value or contributed, have not gone through with their meta-analysis yet (although I’m aware that it takes some time.) - Slight scumlean.
Alice - No poster
ModeShifter - Has also not contributed to the conversation in any positive way, continually drawing back to things that are unimportant. - Slight scumlean.
Italy is always scum - Even with over 30 posts, has not contributed to the topic in the slightest. - Slight scumlean.
Twil1ight - Despite taking things a bit too seriously, is actually semi-active and willing to participate in valid discussion and look at people, taking meta into account. Townlean.
an_gorta_pratai - Had a poor start to the day, and hasn’t really bounced back from it. I have them as null due to this, and their lack of a defense. It’s also possible that they could be a neutral, claiming Citizen to prevent an attack from Coven. - Neutral (not null!)
Marshal - Actually tried to stimulate conversation. While it could be powerwolfing, it seems more like a genuine attempt to get the topic going. They have also provided a few reads, and are contributing a decent, if small amount (in comparison to their total post count.) - Slight townlean.
CRichard564 - I haven’t really been able to get a read on them. Like Tw1light, takes things a bit too seriously, but doesn’t really push forward or get overly defensive about things. - Null.
katze - Not really sure what to make of this slot due to my own bias, but they seem to be playing… Decently? Their memes leave something to be desired, however, and they seem to have continued leaning into it, and others’ have been commenting that this is not a weird thing for katze to do. - Null/Neutral.
clonedcheese - Have been… almost annoying neutral. They’ve responded to others’ posts, but haven’t made any reads of their own, or really said anything unprompted. - Slight scumlean.
TheBlueElixir - One of the more active members of the thread, has been able to talk a bit about their own ideas and reflect others. No real strong opinions, however. - Townlean.
EVO - Not a lot of posts. Unlike other low posters, they have responded to plenty of people and have given their own thoughts without seeming 100% serious all of the time. - Townlean.
SogMan - They’ve posted a lot, mostly their own opinions however, and haven’t really been able to follow anything up with reasoning. They’ve kept responding to other people to a minimum. - Null.
Fossil - Has said just about nothing, and their posts have been kinda bad. Their temp vote on Marshal seems to be entirely a joke. - Slight scumlean.
PokemonKidRyan - They started off poorly, but in a different manner than they started off their most recent scum match. They are actually somewhat contributing, even though they have been under fire for a bit of the match.
Universal - No poster
Magnus - Nothing they say makes sense, they are actively admitting to avoiding questions, and are overall playing poorly and haven’t contributed at all. - Scumlean.
Wallpost numero uno
Aelin:
Wazza - I can definitely believe the town vigi claim, due to their insistence that I&OI we have no scumreads by EoD, we vote them so they can’t be used to kill other town. - Townlean
N.1 - Haven’t seen much of them whatsoever, stand by the idea that they have been wasting time talking about doing meta and seventeen hours later, still haven’t produced results. I would not be surprised to see them flip scum if they turn up claiming they were unable to do it. - Scumlean
Alice - I can most definitely see Alice claiming vet as an incentive not to get destroyed by Coven for the first few nights, and based on other people talking about their skill level, I entirely believe this to be within their means. I doubt a wolf would do this either, as the risk of doing it with a vet as wolf far outweighs the benefits. Their insistence on NOT lynching Marshall also makes sense, because they are aware that they are not vet, but there would be no way for a wolf to know that, which would get them killed at a 1:1 rate with town, which is +EV for Coven. - Townlean
ModeShifter - Making poor reads and poor plays, so, since it’s Seth, obvious - Townlean
Italy - I absolutely hate their hardclaim, especially with a TPwr already. This doesn’t even get into the fact that they did not participate in the slighest for a very long amount of time. They also actively encouraged the thunderdome, and have not provided any reads of their own. Also, just to make them mad, they are scum for the amount of times they have rolled scum. - Scumlean
oB_Light - This piece of garbage formafia player didn’t say anything for 17 hours - Lockscum Twil1ight - Although they started the day off with plenty of conclusions, they reapproached with much more rationality and logic than the rest of y’all did. Provided some basic townreads, but did not go all the way through the list, nor did they provide explanations. A good start, and will be fine with reevaluating after they get some sleep and come back. - Null for now, waiting for re-eval.
an_gorta_pratai - I stick by my earlier reads, as they haven’t posted in the entire time that I’ve been gone.
Marshal - I can’t really blame them for not picking up on Alice’s queues (mostly since I didn’t see them either), and like I said earlier with Alice, cc’ing vet as wolf is far too risky. There is a chance for an executioner play, however I’m planning on playing disregarding that unless it is blatantly obvious, because that would lead to me doubting all of my reads. - Townlean
CRichard564 - Claims mayor, waiting on mech-confirm, do not blame them for not mech-revealing yet, wish that they hadn’t claimed at all. Also their anger at Marshal is entirely misplaced .
katze - I honestly have no idea what to think of katze. Their level of memeing is so high that I honestly have no idea what to think of them. I am also pretty sure that they pride themselves on being hard to read and they’re sure living up to that . I will leave reads on katze to people who have more experience with them. - Null.
clonedcheese - Was inactive for a while, but came back with a readlist that actually implemented f’ing logic and thought, although it was more basic. I would love to see some more reasoning behind some of their reads, specifically Italy and PKR. I believe that PKR’s claim was purely an example, and haven’t seen anything heavily suggesting otherwise. - Slight townlean.
TheBlueElixir - I am liking this slot a bit, although they have made some poor plays, and still have no real defined reads of their own on most of the game, mostly focusing on a few select people. They don’t really play like their experience seems to suggest, although that might be unfamiliarity with ToS. For now, - Null.
EVO - Anime pfp so scumlock being serious though, EVO is probably one of my strongest townleans, mostly due to their willingness to look at things from a theoretical standpoint and re-eval, not to mention their readlist whose main problem was the reads on Universal and Magnus lacked any depth whatsoever, considering Magnus’ claim is assumed to be a meme. - Townlean, dying to hear deeper analysis on those two especially.
SogMan - I’m not really liking much from this slot. They passively helped along the thunderdome, and haven’t contributed much to the discussion… at all. - Scumlean
Fossil - Haven’t contributed whatsoever all game, although I understand real life takes priority, even taking half an hour or so would be helpful. - Null for now, waiting for re-eval.
PokemonKidRyan - While they did mess up a bit at the beginning, they have bounced back and done their best to stir up some conversation. But then they got drunk and haven’t really been seen since other than a half dozen or so posts with no content. - Null, waiting for re-eval.
Universal - They came in a bit really late, but provided a bit a memeiness, some few basic reads, however, they haven’t really committed to catching up on the reading. I can’t say I blame them, but will wait for their ISO’s before I make any further opinions. - Null, waiting for re-eval.
Magnus - I still don’t really like their beginning, and they haven’t really helped their case since then. I can understand taking a day off, but it doesn’t mean that I like it. They haven’t participated in any meaningful discussion yet, nor made any real reads. They are just sitting at the fringes, poking at stuff, which I don’t like. - Slight scumlean, would like some more activity from them.
Wallpost numero dos
I do have some changed opinions, obviously you subbing in to the N.1 slot leans to the fact that they were genuinely busy, so you are null atm. Italy… I still don’t really know about, and will wait until N1 results before going further in depth on their read. I missed TheBlueElixer’s reads when I posted my second wallpost, so you can attribute that however you’d like. I don’t like Wazza going back and forth and back and forth, but, once again, will wait for N1 results. Universal has showed up, has provided a bit of content and some ISO, a slight townlean but not crazy high. @Zone_Q11
