FoL Feedback Thread

[DatBird]

@katze

Is there a limit to how many of X class can spawn? I feel like this is one of those “hosts discretion” kind of rules and should probably have a more official answer somewhere. Even if math makes it quite unlikely to get more than 2-3

like every class should have at the max 3

[katze]

how I answered/handled the mechquestions

@katze

Do Knight/Alchemist suicide if they attack a healed BD? A death immune BD?

I answered that if the BD was DI they wouldn’t suicide and if they were healed they would suicide, because that’s how it works in ToL and I couldn’t find any precedent here.

@katze

If a Possessor strings somebody, if that kill is exhumed will the strung persons alignment be revealed or will it always be Neutral?

I answered Neutral always because it didn’t really make sense to me otherwise, but the person who asked insisted I was wrong.

@katze

If a Sellsword stonewalls a target who a CW ice wards, does the Ice Ward or Stonewall take priority?

I ended up going with Stonewall because I had to pick one in my mind and it made more sense for this to win imo

@katze

If a Noble bounties someone who is disguised, does the disguised role determine whether or not the day continues or their true one? Like a Fool flipping BD or a Scorned disguising a BD as non-BD.

I thought yes, but Frost said no, so I said no. Glad I was corrected here.

@katze

Is there a limit to how many of X class can spawn? I feel like this is one of those “hosts discretion” kind of rules and should probably have a more official answer somewhere. Even if math makes it quite unlikely to get more than 2-3

I said no to this one but I really think there should be an official limit

@DatBird

why wouldnt it be. If it wasnt then no one would know and what would be the point

I ended up assuming it’d be announced because it can be extremely obvious if it’s in effect

[Arete]

@katze

the Devout Kings classcard has Grand Trial listed twice.

fixed, thank you

[DatBird]

@katze

I answered that if the BD was DI they wouldn’t suicide

Im sorry to ask but how can BD become death immune for the problem to happen, im genuinly lost on that part maybe except king. If so I think to keep it consistent we have to go one or the other. That or have the doc with interactions specifically say that. Like idk i still feel the knight would feel guilty for attacking one of his own, but we could make a pole

@katze

@katze

If a Possessor strings somebody, if that kill is exhumed will the strung persons alignment be revealed or will it always be Neutral?

I answered Neutral always because it didn’t really make sense to me otherwise, but the person who asked insisted I was wrong.

This one is a dousy cause theres a case for both, I could reach out to Solic and see if he knew, if not we can decide.

@katze

@katze

If a Sellsword stonewalls a target who a CW ice wards, does the Ice Ward or Stonewall take priority?

I ended up going with Stonewall because I had to pick one in my mind and it made more sense for this to win imo

SS is immune to Occupation and is a neut so I would give them priortity over others. but again we could pole this

@katze

@katze

If a Noble bounties someone who is disguised, does the disguised role determine whether or not the day continues or their true one? Like a Fool flipping BD or a Scorned disguising a BD as non-BD.

I thought yes, but Frost said no, so I said no. Glad I was corrected here.

what arete said

@katze

I said no to this one but I really think there should be an official limit

there is 3 per class, not class type. So realistically we could have 5 invests but not 5 paladins. But usually u kinda want to reroll at like 5 invests, cause its prob gonna be sided

[katze]

@DatBird

except king

bingo, i think this is the only way in FoL

@DatBird

But usually u kinda want to reroll at like 5 invests, cause its prob gonna be sided

laughs nervously

[DatBird]

its ok, no worries

[Arete]

@DatBird

This one is a dousy cause theres a case for both, I could reach out to Solic and see if he knew, if not we can decide.

My personal inclination is ‘neutral like in ToL,’ if I had to justify that I would say that having someone randomly show up as killed by BD when no BD claim the kill, or killed by Cult on N1, or whatever would semi-out a Possessor game, which seems kind of unfair to the Poss

[DatBird]

Im fine with that. I did reach out to Solic though if he ever encountered it

[katze]

it’d also give the possessor information as to who they’re stringing (if a physician exists), which im not sure is a good or bad thing

[DatBird]

So i think thats mostly settled then. Poss will be the one seen not the puppet

[DatBird]

Solic agreed on the neut ruling

[sulit]

I don’t know if this would fly, but maybe try balancing things players-wise as well?

[orangeandblack5]

nope

[orangeandblack5]

ban sulit 2020

[sulit]

sad noises

[orangeandblack5]

(Actually though hosts should just re-roll games that will clearly be unfun. This can be a bad rand, or a bad player distribution.)

[Arete]

How do people feel about, as a minor NK buff, making it so that NKs know when occupied/occ-attempted or redirected/redirect-attempted (like currently is true with Mastermind)? This makes it easier for NKs to fakeclaim investigative and removes the ‘he knew he was occ’d, he can’t be NK’ thing that happened this past game.

[Arete]

@orangeandblack5

nope

+1

[Frostwolf103]

@orangeandblack5

(Actually though hosts should just re-roll games that will clearly be unfun. This can be a bad rand, or a bad player distribution.)

Apparently I did wrong where N.1 did right?

[orangeandblack5]

I have no idea what you mean