FoL Feedback Thread

Forum Matches Forum of Lies
#5764

Actually I’ma put a suggestion down for that

#5765

killing a large amount of unconfirmed people

#5766

I would make it have either

One use trigger to ignite
If you kill BD you cant ignite anymore

#5767

We’d probably end up doing both indeed.

1 Like
#5768

Do both duh

#5769

Oh I see

Yeah no not on my Ranger

Please feel free to submit your own focused around that idea though, maybe I won’t dislike it if the other abilities synergize well

Also give it counterplay so if it outs the scum can deal with it

#5770

But like. Just having it be an arsonist ends up with it being a slightly more specialized Knight

#5771

is that bad

#5772

I don’t think it’s a BAD idea

#5773

Then find a twist

#5774

also occupies the person you kill?

#5775

Basically. In order for a town arso to be more useful than a town vig you need to:

A: Find 3 or more scum at once
B: Have already marked them
C: Be the only TK available

If A isn’t true then a Knight is just as fast. 1 Scum is lynched and the other is CSed.
If B isn’t true then in the time it would take to mark them the Knight could have CSed them instead.
If C isn’t true then you have enough TK’s that the AoE effect of the arso doesn’t matter.

The odds of all that happening are very low. And while yes you are more likely to find multiple scum at once in FoL, you are also more likely to be able to coordinate killing all of them and are also more likely to take a TK’s accusation seriously in the first place.

#5776

Ah but you fail to realize that killing town is helpful for the POE, while a knight punishes heavily upon killing town. A town vigilante that can only kill town is helpful even if it doesn’t seem helpful

#5777

Irrelevant. That’s a reason for a guiltless vig, not for a town arsonist

#5778

No it isn’t, the fact that arsonist can kill town while not killing itself is HUGE in itself, and it’s what make Arsonist so good. You kill all the scummy players that you doubt will be lynched/killed and you douse them while you lynch other scummy players. Even if you kill own town or two you basically are the POE eliminator

1 Like
#5779

In that time a guiltless vig could have already killed them

#5780

I mean

It needs more than just that

But yes it is a nice aspect

1 Like
#5781

Are you suggesting we add a guiltless vigilante which is a better knight

1 Like
#5782

That’s likely not happening, unless you can think of a good reason it should?

1 Like
#5783

No. I’m suggesting we DON’T add a town arsonist, which btw isn’t inherently guiltless