FoL Feedback Thread

[Icibalus]

Also, no offence to anybody but PR reading is beyond like 90% of FM players

[eevee]

Ekhm.

[Firekitten]

I agree with ici mostly

[Firekitten]

“There’s a difference between maliciously offending somebody - on purpose - and somebody being offended by…truth. If you’re offended by the truth, that’s your problem. I have no obligation to not offend you if I’m speaking the truth. The truth is supposed to offend you; that’s how you know you don’t got it.“

[Solic]

Absolute truths exists y’all.

[eevee]

PR reading is easy, at least on some basic tier.

Not everyone needs to read poison healer as poison healer in 80 person mash on day 2, without claim.

[Icibalus]

My point is that is essentially what Hjasik is saying is the main source of fun with Inquisitor.

[eevee]

But PR reading with Inq is rather easy.

[Icibalus]

“you can get an epic win if you tell apart an Observer from a Princess despite the fact that statistically they play the same!”

[Firekitten]

is it fun?

[Icibalus]

Okay, I’m interested. This seems to be a gap in my knowledge.

How could one actually tell apart one mid-strength PR from another?

[eevee]

@Icibalus

“you can get an epic win if you tell apart an Observer from a Princess despite the fact that statistically they play the same!”

They don’t.
ToL treats obs as way more damning evidence and hence is plaied way mire impulsive when saying someone is/is not guilty.

Princesses are by general way more cautiois and playing around with theirs results, or they just straightforward claim them if they don’t know what to do, wich is even easier.

[Geyde]

@Wazza

Ruthless Will (Night) - Attack one of your targets, they must be found using Interrogate or Visiting Cleanse before hand. - 3 uses.

Why does this rely on checking them first

[eevee]

@Icibalus

Okay, I’m interested. This seems to be a gap in my knowledge.

How could one actually tell apart one mid-strength PR from another?

Actualy that was a gambit from UN mash wich let me to concluaion who is poison healer without them claiming it.
Also theu were super scummy and town came to conclusion to hung them day after I died and I couldn’t defend them.
Sas times.

[eevee]

@eevee-sama

Also theu were super scummy and town came to conclusion to hung them day after I died and I couldn’t defend them.

Oh yea, I love PR hunting as town.

[Icibalus]

You have a point. Now how does one tell those two apart from a Sheriff or a Physician, who will both get information similar to the former and one info similar to the latter?

If I can prove that PR hunting in the way that Inquisitor would require is A: way too difficult or B: just not fun I think we can call the idea soundly rejected.

[Geyde]

@Icibalus

A: way too difficult

@Icibalus

Read EFoL 2 when I was fanatic.
It’s not that hard.

[Geyde]

Ended up reading 4 softs from BD players correctly, figured out most of the scumteam, and the neutral killer.

Random guessing did play a role in that though tbf

[eevee]

Or should I bring out my famous statement from 2 years ago on hydra event on MU - “XYZ is town mason or mafia goon”

…

They were mason

…

That probably wasn’t smart.

[eevee]

@Icibalus

You have a point. Now how does one tell those two apart from a Sheriff or a Physician, who will both get information similar to the former and one info similar to the latter?

If I can prove that PR hunting in the way that Inquisitor would require is A: way too difficult or B: just not fun I think we can call the idea soundly rejected.

ToL roles are more complicated, so it’s harder, I agree.

But still possible.