FoL Feedback Thread

[Arete]

@Marshal

literally that ability does shit against NK and is just hella weak

I mean

The same was already true of FoL defend vs. most NKs

[SirDerpsAlot]

If you’re gonna go that route just remove defend or make it bypass bleed immunity at least

[SirDerpsAlot]

Does it not go through NKs like ToL?

[Marshal]

it doesn’t

but at least the knight doesn’t just fuckin croak

[Arete]

Correct, it doesn’t bypass immunity

[SirDerpsAlot]

Okay so yes I say just remove defend at this point then

[anon97870008]

never defend after n2, or the game ends before your bleeding can proc

[Arete]

I mean Defend is still useful even without the Armored passive

Not sure I agree with the bleed thing

[SirDerpsAlot]

Just don’t defend it’s more usefull to just straight vig someone

[SirDerpsAlot]

Withought killing anyone instantly I see no reason I would ever want to use it

[Ami]

@Icibalus

7) Elite Bodygaurds

Choose a player each night. If that player is attacked, you will die to kill their attacker.

This role is an omniscient town doctor vig which comes at the TINY disadvantage of dying when they save somebody. Again, including something like this in your game, even though it’s extremely commonly used, will make your game majorly townsided, and here’s the crucial thing; completely unfun. The Bodygaurd dosen’t have a fun job, because simply predicting who dies and then getting a free kill feels cheap, and no wonder. The scum sweat far too much about their nightkills and have to needlessly fret about every facet of their plan at night, when the scum should be having fun at night.

ici is someone who i know knows their shit so im just gonna quote this

[anon97870008]

He says the same about prince in that thread. And?

[SirDerpsAlot]

My mentality when I have something like knight has now that dosent kill is “my reads are probably better than who would die so I’ll no action instead of risking death”

[Ami]

why does that disqualify him for having opinions about balance in FM

[anon97870008]

That thread obv cant apply to fol then.

[Geyde]

Ici’s opinions are regarding general FM
He’s said himself that ToL/FoL’s insanely high power necessitates it at some level

[Ami]

i personally think it’s gotten too high power imo and i would prefer to scale it back, but thats just me personally.

though i do think an elite bodyguard is fuckin dumb in general

[Geyde]

But 3-shot vig in any case is very very very very strong

[Geyde]

@Ami

i personally think it’s gotten too high power imo and i would prefer to scale it back, but thats just me personally.

though i do think an elite bodyguard is fuckin dumb in general

I agree that it’s too powerful
But scaling back would make an entirely different game

[Ami]

then what would you make a guiltless CS?