FoL Feedback Thread

Forum Matches Forum of Lies
#11309

Just remove alch

#11310

It doesn’t add anything unique to the game
I tried reworking it but it ended up still being a kingmaker

#11311

Just make neuts neut again. Most neuts right now aren’t really neutral, but pretty hard siding by mechanics.

#11312

I could try reworking it to a support that helps evils, though.

#11313

WELL technically.
But in how many games do you see this in fact happening?

#11314
1 Like
#11315

The problem is that nobody likes playing survivors.

1 Like
#11316

Oh god, that was a nice, 100% neutral class. I loved it.

#11317

Who doesn’t like survivors? What do you mean with that

#11318

Roles who need to survive until endgame to win. Most people find it extremely boring which is why the Alch was originally removed.

#11319

Fool and Alch were removed because of personal opinions of a few, not more. There was no real reason for it as far as I can see.

#11320

Actually a decent amount
If you want an example of neutral kingmaking, then look no further than SFoL 37 (iirc), SFoL 44, and FoL 23 where neuts that were already pretty much guaranteed to win being able to potentially decide the match

#11321

This is the most egregious example

#11322

Fool was removed as their goal was braindead easy in FoL. You’d almost always see d2 Fool wins before it was reworked.

#11323

What happened in FoL 23?

#11324

I thought people hated alch

#11325

FoL is long
You don’t do much solving as a survivor

#11326

if you don’t, you’re doing something wrong

#11327

Scorned won
Scorned could have handed the game to either BD or NK

They handed it to BD

#11328

Which is why it was removed. Polls back showed that an overwhelming amount of players wanted it gone/reworked.